Skip to content

Why your low end lies in a small room

Below about 200 Hz a small room boosts some notes and swallows others, depending on where you sit. EQ cannot fill a null, so work out your room modes first.

Updated · 7 min read Lesson 13 of 14 in Audio Science

In short

  1. Bass wavelengths are as long as the room, so a small room turns into a set of resonances, the room modes, at f = n × 343 / (2L).
  2. Each mode is loud at the walls and has nulls at fixed places, so what you hear at the desk depends on where the desk is.
  3. EQ cannot fill a null. Know your modes, treat the corners, move the chair and check bass decisions away from the room.
In this lesson (8)

The car test

You spend two hours on the low end. The kick and the 808 sit together, and the sub feels warm and full. You bounce the track, walk to the car, press play, and the bass is overwhelming. Or the opposite happens: what felt like a wall of bass at the desk turns thin and hollow in the car.

Your speakers and interface are probably fine, and the room is the likely cause. Below a couple of hundred hertz, a small room boosts some bass notes and cancels others, and the pattern changes when you move.

Why it matters

Bass waves are bigger than the room

Every frequency has a wavelength:

λ=cf\lambda = \frac{c}{f}

where cc is the speed of sound, about 343 m/s at room temperature. A 1 kHz tone has a wavelength of 34 cm. A 50 Hz bass note has a wavelength of 6.9 m, longer than most home studios. At these sizes the whole room behaves as a resonator with a handful of strong , and what you hear at the desk depends on where the desk sits inside that pattern.

Figure 1. Wavelength is 343 m/s divided by frequency. Every note below about 86 Hz has a wavelength longer than a 4 m room, so the room acts as a resonator instead of a set of walls that sound bounces off.

That is why low-end decisions made at the desk do not translate. Sit where the room cancels 65 Hz and the kick sounds thin, so you boost it. In the car there is no such cancellation, and the boost is simply too much 65 Hz.

The science

Room modes

Between two parallel walls a distance LL apart, sound reflecting back and forth builds at the frequencies where a whole number of half wavelengths fits between the walls. These are the axial modes:

fn=n c2L,n=1,2,3,…f_n = \frac{n\,c}{2L}, \quad n = 1, 2, 3, \dots

For a room 4 m long, the first is 343/(2×4)≈43343 / (2 \times 4) \approx 43 Hz, then 86 Hz and 129 Hz. Each pair of surfaces, front and back, side and side, floor and ceiling, has its own series. A room 4 m long, 3.5 m wide and 2.5 m high has these:

DimensionLengthFirst modeSecond mode
Length4.0 m43 Hz86 Hz
Width3.5 m49 Hz98 Hz
Height2.5 m69 Hz137 Hz

Modes that bounce between two or three pairs of surfaces also exist, but the axial ones are usually the strongest.

A standing wave has a fixed shape. For mode nn, the pressure varies along the room as cos⁡(nπx/L)\cos(n \pi x / L), where xx is the distance from one wall. Pressure is always highest at the walls and in the corners, which is why bass builds up there. The first mode has a null in the middle of the room. The second has nulls at a quarter and three quarters of the length. At a null that frequency almost disappears, and a metre away it can be loud.

Figure 2. Pressure along a 4 m room, front wall to back wall, for the first two length modes. The two lines show the extremes of each standing wave. Both are loudest at the walls. The first vanishes in the middle, the second at 1 m and 3 m, so a chair 1 m from the wall hears almost no 86 Hz.

Put a desk 1 m from the front wall of the 4 m room and you sit on the null of the 86 Hz mode while 43 Hz is still strong. 43 Hz sounds boomy, so you turn the sub down; 86 Hz sounds weak, so you push it up. In the car both decisions are wrong.

The speakers have their own version of this. Sound from a woofer also reflects off the wall behind it, and at the frequency where that detour is half a wavelength, the reflection cancels the direct sound: f=c/(4d)f = c / (4d), where dd is the distance from the woofer to the wall. A speaker 0.5 m from the wall gets a dip near 170 Hz.

Higher up, the modes crowd together and blur into ordinary reverberation. A common estimate of where that happens is the Schroeder frequency, fS≈2000T60/Vf_S \approx 2000 \sqrt{T_{60} / V}, with reverb time T60T_{60} in seconds and room volume VV in cubic metres (Schroeder, 1996). For the 35 m³ room above with a reverb time of 0.4 s, that is about 210 Hz. Below it, think in modes.

Try it

Map your room

0 of 7 steps done

The loud and quiet frequencies sit close to the modes you calculated, and they move when you move. That is the room, not the mix.

Common mistake

Trying to EQ out a null

A null is a cancellation. Boost that frequency, in the mix or with room correction, and you feed more energy into both of the waves that are cancelling. They still cancel at your chair, and the frequency gets louder everywhere else. Room correction can usefully pull down peaks, which are excess energy, but it cannot fill a null.

The other mistake is buying thin foam for bass. A 2.5 cm foam tile does very little below a few hundred hertz, and a 43 Hz wave is 8 m long. What helps is thick porous absorption across the corners, where the pressure of every mode is highest, and a listening position away from the exact middle of the room and away from the quarter points.

Takeaway

Make bass decisions with more than one ear

Keep a list of your room's modes by the desk, so you know which notes the room exaggerates and which it hides. Treat the corners if you can, move the chair off the middle and the quarter points, and place the speakers symmetrically between the side walls. Then check every low-end decision somewhere the room cannot reach: good headphones, a car, a whose bass you know well. If the reference sounds thin at your desk too, the room has a dip there, and your mix does not need a boost.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. A room is 5 m long. Where is its first length mode?
  2. You sit in a null at 65 Hz and boost 65 Hz by 6 dB. What happens?
  3. Why do bass traps go in the corners?

Sources

Show all 3
  • Schroeder, M. R. (1996). The "Schroeder frequency" revisited. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 99(5), 3240-3241.
  • Toole, F. E. (2017). Sound Reproduction: The Acoustics and Psychoacoustics of Loudspeakers and Rooms (3rd ed.). Routledge.
  • MIT OpenCourseWare. 8.03SC Physics III: Vibrations and Waves, Fall 2016. ocw.mit.edu/courses/8-03sc-physics-iii-vibrations-and-waves-fall-2016/

Next lesson · 14 of 14

Every plugin is maths with knobsUnder every plugin interface is an equation that turns input samples into output samples. A null test against your stock tools shows what a plugin really adds.

Previous: Latency changes how a take feels

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.