Skip to content

How constraints make taste sharper

Endless sounds let you hide a weak part behind layers. A five-track limit forces the fix into the notes, the voicing and the rhythm, where taste shows.

Updated · 5 min read Lesson 5 of 10 in Producer Mindset

In short

  1. A constraint narrows the search, so your effort goes into the part instead of into choosing sounds.
  2. Research suggests the benefit has a peak: some limits help, and too many starve the work.
  3. Write a hook with five tracks and no layering, and fix weak parts by changing notes, voicing and rhythm.
In this lesson (8)

An hour of browsing kicks

You open your DAW to start a new track. There are dozens of virtual synths and gigabytes of drum samples on an external drive. You spend the first hour clicking through kicks and loading huge pads you will delete later. By the time you have a basic drum pattern, your focus is gone and you have not written a single musical phrase.

In the digital studio, selection has replaced execution. Because every sound is available, you can put off the hard choice of committing to a direction. You browse instead of building.

Why it matters

Unlimited layers hide weak parts

With no limits, taste gets lazy. Instead of writing a stronger lead, you stack three synth presets to make a thin line sound big. You cover a weak arrangement with noise sweeps and ambient pads.

That clutter also makes the song hard to mix. With sixty tracks competing for the same space, is almost certain, and the mix turns into surgical that carves holes for parts that should never have been in the session. A track built from many weak layers rarely has the punch and clarity of a sparse one where every part has a job.

The science

Constraints help, up to a point

Constraints can improve creative work, and there is direct evidence for it. Haught-Tromp (2017) asked people to write two-line rhymes for greeting cards. When they had to include a given noun, their rhymes were rated as more creative than rhymes written with no such rule, and the effect held in a second study where people picked their own nouns in advance. The results also suggested that practising with the constraint carried over to later rhymes.

The benefit is not unlimited. Acar, Tarakci and van Knippenberg (2019) reviewed research on constraints across several disciplines, found the results conflicting and proposed that the relationship is curved. Some constraint focuses attention and effort. Too much leaves too little room to work.

Figure 1. The shape Acar, Tarakci and van Knippenberg (2019) propose from a cross-disciplinary review: some constraint focuses the search, and too much starves it. A shape, not a measurement.

A limit works in the studio because it narrows the search. With five tracks, you cannot answer "the hook feels weak" by adding a sixth, so the answer has to come from the notes: a wider chord voicing, a different bass rhythm, a velocity change on the hats. That is also the condition under which a big menu of sounds hurts most, when you do not yet know what you want (see the lesson on plugin choices).

Try it

The five-track hook

0 of 7 steps done

You should hear every part clearly. Either the hook works with five parts, or the limit shows you exactly which part of the writing is weak.

Common mistake

Layering to fix a weak part

Adding tracks feels like the way to a bigger sound. Three pads and a guitar loop playing the same chords do not add up to a bigger chord. Their attacks smear into each other and their ranges mask each other, so a sharp, rhythmic progression turns into a soft wall. If a melody does nothing for you on a plain piano, ten synth layers will not fix it.

Figure 2. Five tracks, no layers. Contrast comes from which parts play in which section: the lead sits out the intro and verse and enters on the hook, so its entrance is heard as an event instead of being buried under a stack.

The opposite mistake is a limit so tight it starves the song, such as one sound for a whole album. Pick constraints that force a decision, then give yourself room inside them.

Takeaway

Choose the palette before you write

Treat limits as part of the writing. Before you start a song, pick the drum kit and the two or three sounds the song is built on, and commit to them for the session. Set a track limit and a timer, and fix weak moments by changing what the parts play.

You cannot hide behind layers inside a small palette, so your choices get clearer and your sound gets more recognizable. Taste shows in what you leave out.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. Why can a five-track limit produce a better hook than sixty tracks?
  2. The five-track limit sharpened your last hook, so this time you allow one track, one sound and five minutes for a whole song. What does the review by Acar and colleagues suggest you should expect?
  3. Your hook feels weak inside the five-track limit. What is the right move?

Sources

Show all 2
  • Acar, O. A., Tarakci, M., & van Knippenberg, D. (2019). Creativity and innovation under constraints: A cross-disciplinary integrative review. Journal of Management, 45(1), 96-121.
  • Haught-Tromp, C. (2017). The Green Eggs and Ham hypothesis: How constraints facilitate creativity. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts, 11(1), 10-17.

Next lesson · 6 of 10

Why vibe needs measurable decisionsWarm, muddy and punchy are useful words once each one points at something you can measure. Change one parameter, match the level and compare fast.

Previous: When too many plugin choices stall a mix

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.