Skip to content

Distortion adds size without more volume

Saturation adds harmonics and lifts the average level against the peak, so a part sounds bigger at the same loudness. Level-match to hear it.

Updated · 6 min read Lesson 6 of 10 in Sound Design

In short

  1. Saturation adds harmonics at multiples of each note, in a range that small speakers play and the ear hears easily.
  2. Rounding the peaks lowers the crest factor, so a saturated part carries more average level at the same peak.
  3. Match loudness before you judge, and stop driving once the part sits forward at the same level.
In this lesson (8)

A bass that is either invisible or too loud

Your bass is too quiet. On a laptop you cannot follow the bass line at all, so you push the fader. Now it is loud enough, but its peaks hit the master ceiling and the starts squeezing the whole mix. You pull it back and the bass disappears again. There seems to be no setting between invisible and too loud.

Turning a clean sound up raises every part of it by the same amount, peaks included, so the peaks reach the ceiling first. On a small speaker it barely helps anyway, because most of the bass energy sits below what that speaker can play. changes the sound itself, so it can be heard more without peaking higher.

Why it matters

Harmonics and a smaller crest factor

Saturation adds new frequencies at whole-number multiples of each note. A 55 Hz bass note gains energy at 110, 165, 220 Hz and up, where small speakers can play it and the ear is more sensitive than it is in the deep bass (Moore, 2012). The note becomes easier to hear without its getting any louder.

Saturation also rounds off peaks, which lowers the , the gap between peak and average level. A pure sine has a crest factor of about 3 dB. Clip it hard and it approaches a square wave, whose crest factor is 0 dB. At the same peak level the clipped wave carries more average energy, so it reads louder and denser while the peak meter stays put.

Figure 1. All three peak at the same level. The clipped versions spend more of each cycle near the top, so they carry more average energy and read louder on the same peak meter.

Listen

Hear saturation add size, not volume

Bass and chords, or a real mix, through a waveshaper, level-matched so you hear the harmonics rather than a louder signal. Watch the spectrum fill in.

Loading demo…
100%

Start with your speakers or headphones low.

The science

A curve that bends

, delay and reverb are linear. They can change the level and of frequencies that are already there, and nothing more. A saturator is nonlinear: it bends the relationship between input and output, and a bent curve makes new frequencies.

A common soft clipper is the cubic curve (Smith, Physical Audio Signal Processing):

f(x)=x−x33,∣x∣≤1f(x) = x - \frac{x^3}{3}, \quad |x| \le 1

Beyond ∣x∣=1|x| = 1 the output stays at ±2/3\pm 2/3. The cubic is the start of the Taylor series of tanh⁡\tanh, another classic soft clipper:

tanh⁡x=x−x33+2x515−…\tanh x = x - \frac{x^3}{3} + \frac{2x^5}{15} - \dots

Feed the cubic a sine, x=Asin⁡ωtx = A \sin \omega t, and use sin⁡3θ=14(3sin⁡θ−sin⁡3θ)\sin^3 \theta = \tfrac{1}{4}(3 \sin \theta - \sin 3\theta):

f(x)=(A−A34)sin⁡ωt+A312sin⁡3ωtf(x) = \left( A - \frac{A^3}{4} \right) \sin \omega t + \frac{A^3}{12} \sin 3\omega t

So the cubic makes exactly one new frequency, the third harmonic. At full input (A=1A = 1) it sits about 19 dB below the fundamental, and at half input about 33 dB below. Because it grows with A3A^3, the edge arrives quickly once you push. Curves with higher-order terms, such as tanh⁡\tanh, add the fifth, seventh and further odd , and a hard clip adds a long series of them, which is why it sounds harsher.

Figure 2. Input against output. The soft curve bends gradually, so quiet signals pass almost clean and harmonics grow as you push. The hard curve is clean up to the ceiling and then flat, and that sudden corner makes many more high harmonics.

A curve that treats the positive and negative halves of the wave the same way, like all of these, makes only odd harmonics. An asymmetric curve, such as a single-ended tube stage, adds even harmonics too. The second harmonic is an octave above the note and blends in, while the odd ones add more edge. That is a rule of thumb, not a law, but it is a useful one.

Try it

The level-matched distortion test

Prove to yourself that saturation adds size as well as level.

0 of 7 steps done

At matched loudness the saturated bass sounds denser and closer, and you can follow it on a laptop speaker. When you halve the drive, the edge falls away much faster than the level does. If you cannot hear a difference once levels match, the drive was only making it louder.

Common mistake

More drive is not more size

Past a point, more drive takes size away. Hard flattens the of every hit, so the kick loses its punch and the bass loses its attack. When two or more notes go through a nonlinear curve together, as in a distorted chord, they also produce : new tones at the sums and differences of the notes, which are not in key and sound muddy (Reiss and McPherson, 2014). And every harmonic that lands above the folds back down as , covered in the lesson on aliasing.

The other mistake is judging without matching level. Saturation almost always adds loudness, and the louder version wins a careless comparison.

Takeaway

Saturate for density, decide at matched level

Use saturation where a part needs to be heard more without peaking higher: bass, vocals, snare, synths. Drive in small steps, match loudness after each one, and stop when the part sits forward at the same level. On bass, try it in parallel: saturate a copy, the copy and blend it in, so the harmonics help on small speakers while the sub stays clean. The lesson on bass for small speakers walks through that setup.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. A cubic soft clipper, x - x³/3, is fed a pure sine. Which new frequency appears?
  2. A saturated and a clean version peak at the same level. Why does the saturated one sound louder?
  3. Why match loudness before you judge a saturator?

Sources

Show all 3
  • Moore, B. C. J. (2012). An Introduction to the Psychology of Hearing (6th ed.). Emerald.
  • Reiss, J. D., & McPherson, A. (2014). Audio Effects: Theory, Implementation and Application. CRC Press.
  • Smith, J. O. Physical Audio Signal Processing. CCRMA, Stanford University. ccrma.stanford.edu/~jos/pasp/

Next lesson · 7 of 10

Small speakers need bass harmonicsA phone cannot play a 50 Hz sub, but it can play the harmonics above it, and the ear rebuilds the pitch from them. Design bass that survives small speakers.

Previous: Noise can make synths breathe

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.