Skip to content

Phase is timing with consequences

Two copies of a sound add up or cancel depending on their timing. Fix polarity and alignment on related mics before you reach for EQ, then check the mix in mono.

Updated · 6 min read Lesson 9 of 14 in Audio Science

In short

  1. Two copies of a sound reinforce when they are in step and cancel half a cycle apart, so their sum depends on timing.
  2. A polarity flip inverts every frequency at once. A delay cancels a comb of frequencies, starting at one over twice the delay.
  3. Fix polarity and alignment on related mics before you reach for EQ, then check the mix in mono.
In this lesson (8)

The snare that EQ cannot thicken

You are mixing a snare recorded with two microphones, one above the top head and one below the bottom head. Together they sound thin. You boost 200 Hz by 6 dB and the snare gets louder but no thicker. You boost more and it turns hollow and harsh.

The thin sound comes from how the two mics add up. When the stick drives the heads down, the top head moves away from the top mic while the bottom head moves toward the bottom mic, so the two mics produce waveforms of opposite . Added together, they cancel much of the body of the drum. Boosting a frequency that is cancelling boosts both halves of the cancellation.

Why it matters

Two copies, one result

describes where a wave is in its cycle. When two signals that carry the same sound are mixed, their sum depends on how their cycles line up. In step, they reinforce: two equal copies add up to 6 dB louder. Half a cycle apart, they cancel. Anywhere in between, you get something in between.

Figure 1. Two equal sine waves and their sum. In step they add to twice the height, +6 dB. A quarter cycle apart (90 degrees) they add to 1.41 times, +3 dB. Half a cycle apart they cancel completely.

This happens whenever one sound reaches two microphones at different times, whenever a track is layered with a slightly delayed copy of itself, and whenever a stereo trick is folded to mono. The low end is where it hurts most. Low frequencies carry most of the weight of a mix, and two nearby mics pick up nearly the same low-frequency waveform, so their sum depends almost entirely on how well they are aligned.

Listen

Hear two copies of a bass cancel

The same bass note on two layers. Delay one by a few milliseconds or flip its polarity and the low end thins out, then disappears.

Loading demo…
100%

Start with your speakers or headphones low.

The science

Phase, polarity and comb filtering

For two equal sines that differ in phase by Δϕ\Delta\phi, the sum has an amplitude of

A=2cos⁡(Δϕ2)A = 2 \cos\left(\frac{\Delta\phi}{2}\right)

times the amplitude of one of them. At 0 degrees that is 2, or +6 dB. At 90 degrees it is 1.41, or +3 dB. At 120 degrees it is 1, no gain at all, and at 180 degrees it is 0.

A time delay does not shift every frequency by the same angle. A delay of Δt\Delta t moves each frequency ff by 360°×fΔt360° \times f \Delta t, so some frequencies stay in step and others land half a cycle apart. Mixing a sound with a delayed copy of itself cancels every frequency where the delay is an odd number of half cycles:

fnotch=2k+12 Δt,k=0,1,2,…f_{\text{notch}} = \frac{2k + 1}{2\,\Delta t}, \quad k = 0, 1, 2, \dots

With a 1 ms delay the notches sit at 500 Hz, 1.5 kHz, 2.5 kHz and on up, 1 kHz apart. That evenly spaced pattern is . A longer delay pulls the first notch lower: at 5 ms it sits at 100 Hz, right in the punch of a kick.

Figure 2. A sound mixed with an equal copy of itself delayed by 1 ms. Every frequency where the delay is an odd number of half cycles cancels: 500 Hz, 1.5 kHz, 2.5 kHz and on up, 1 kHz apart. Halfway between the notches the two copies add to +6 dB. The notches are evenly spaced in hertz, so on this log scale they crowd together toward the top.

Polarity is a different control. The polarity switch, usually marked Ø, flips the waveform upside down at every frequency at once, with no delay. It fixes the snare top and bottom problem, because those two mics are opposite but almost aligned in time. It cannot fix a time offset, because a delay affects each frequency differently. For that you move the track in time.

Try it

Build cancellations on purpose

0 of 6 steps done

A polarity flip changes every frequency at once. A delay picks out specific frequencies to cancel, and the longer the delay, the lower the damage starts.

Common mistake

Chasing perfect alignment everywhere

With several mics on one source, you cannot align everything at once. If you slide the room mics so they line up with the snare, they are still offset for the toms and cymbals, which sit at different distances. Align the most important source, usually the kick and snare, check the result by ear and leave the rest.

Delays between left and right are also how some stereo width is made. A short delay on one side, the , sounds wide in stereo and turns into comb filtering when the two sides are folded to mono. That is why a mono check matters: a part that relies on such a trick can turn hollow or drop in level on a phone speaker or a mono club system. Only a part that is fully opposite in polarity between left and right vanishes completely.

Takeaway

Check phase before you reach for EQ

When a multi-mic source sounds thin, fix the timing first. Solo the related mics, sum them to mono and flip the polarity of one, then keep whichever setting gives the fullest low end. If a time offset remains, nudge the later track earlier a fraction of a millisecond at a time until the low end locks together. Only then pick up the . Finish with a mono check of the whole mix, listening for the bass and the lead vocal.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. A copy of a track is delayed by 2 ms and mixed back in. Where is the first notch?
  2. Why does a polarity flip fix a snare top and bottom pair, but not two mics at different distances?
  3. Two equal signals are 90 degrees apart at one frequency. How much louder than one of them is their sum at that frequency?

Sources

Show all 2

Next lesson · 10 of 14

What a correlation meter tells youA correlation meter measures how alike the two channels are, weighted by energy. A reading forecasts the mono loss, but a quiet anti-phase part barely moves it.

Previous: Resonance can sing or wreck the mix

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.