Skip to content

Phase and polarity are not the same fix

A polarity flip turns every frequency upside down at once. A delay shifts each frequency by a different angle. Which one you have decides the fix.

Updated · 7 min read Lesson 14 of 44 in Mixing & Mastering

In short

  1. Polarity inverts every frequency at once with no time shift. A delay shifts each frequency by a different angle.
  2. Only related signals cancel reliably: two feeds of one source, like a bass DI and its amp mic, or layers that start together, like a kick and its sub.
  3. Fix the relationship before the tone: polarity first, then timing or phase rotation, and EQ last.
In this lesson (8)

The amp track that makes the bass smaller

You record a bass through a DI and a mic on its amp at the same time, planning to blend the clean low end with the amp's growl. Each track sounds full on its own. Bring the amp up under the DI and the bass gets smaller instead of bigger: the low notes go hollow, as if someone scooped out the bottom with an , and the closer the two tracks get in level, the less bottom is left.

The two signals work against each other, and before you can fix that you need to know whether you are dealing with or . They are related, but they are not the same thing, and they need different fixes.

Why it matters

Cancellation only happens reliably between related signals: two feeds of one source, such as a bass DI and its amp mic or a kick's inside and outside mics, or layers that start together on every hit, such as a kick sample and the sine sub under it. Their relationship is the same every time, so a bad one thins out every single note.

A kick and an unrelated bass line are different. The bass changes notes, so how its waves line up with the kick's changes from hit to hit, and no single polarity setting is right for all of them. That is still worth checking when an 808 or a sub plays the same note as the kick and starts with it, but for a moving bass line the answer is usually arrangement and EQ, not the polarity button.

Whatever the pair, boosting EQ does not fix cancellation. If two signals cancel at a frequency, boosting that frequency on one or both gives you more of each to cancel, and eats on the way.

The science

A flip against a shift

Polarity is a flip. Multiply every sample by -1 and every peak becomes a trough. Every frequency is inverted at the same moment, with no change in timing. The button that does this is often labelled phase or drawn as Ø, which is where much of the confusion starts.

Phase is a position in a cycle, and a delay changes it by an amount that depends on frequency:

Δϕ=360∘×f×Δt\Delta \phi = 360^\circ \times f \times \Delta t

A 1 ms delay is 90 degrees at 250 Hz, 180 degrees at 500 Hz and a full 360 degrees at 1 kHz, where the copies line up again. So a delay does not shift everything by one angle the way a flip does. That is why a flip and a delay only look alike on a pure sine.

Figure 1. The same wave, flipped and delayed. A polarity flip mirrors it top to bottom. A delay slides it later in time and keeps its shape. For a pure sine the two can look alike; for a real sound with harmonics they are clearly different.

When a signal is added to a delayed copy of itself, the frequencies where the delay reaches an odd multiple of 180 degrees cancel. The notches fall at:

fnotch=2k+12τ,k=0,1,2,…f_{\text{notch}} = \frac{2k + 1}{2\tau}, \quad k = 0, 1, 2, \dots

For τ=1\tau = 1 ms that is 500 Hz, 1.5 kHz, 2.5 kHz and on up, a (Smith, 2010). The same formula explains a point that matters for kick and sub: to cancel at 55 Hz you need half a cycle, about 9 ms. A 1 ms offset is only about 20 degrees at 55 Hz and barely touches the sub. Small timing errors hollow out the mids and the click; the deep low end is lost mainly to a polarity mismatch or to a large offset.

Figure 2. One delay of 1 ms, three frequencies, over a 4 ms window. At 250 Hz the copies are 90 degrees apart and the sum is 3 dB below a perfect match. At 500 Hz they are 180 degrees apart and cancel. At 1 kHz they are a full cycle apart and add up again.

Filters shift phase too, without any delay. A , an amp and speaker cabinet, or an analog-style EQ rotates the phase of low frequencies by an amount that changes with frequency (Smith, 2007). Two layers can line up perfectly at the and still fight in the sub range because one of them went through a filter.

Hear both effects on two copies of a bass note. At 55 Hz, about 9 ms of delay puts the layers half a cycle apart.

Listen

Hear two copies of a bass cancel

The same bass note on two layers. Delay one by a few milliseconds or flip its polarity and the low end thins out, then disappears.

Loading demo…
100%

Start with your speakers or headphones low.

Try it

Line up a DI and its amp track

Use a bass recorded through a DI and an amp mic at the same time, like the one in the hook. The amp track arrives late, since sound takes about 1 ms to cross 34 cm of air from the speaker to the mic. The amp and speaker also filter it, which shifts the phase of the lows. Step 5 needs a phase-rotation or all-pass plugin; not every DAW includes one.

0 of 6 steps done

The right setting sounds like one bass, bigger than either track alone, with the amp's growl on top. The wrong one sounds like the DI with the bottom scooped out.

Common mistake

EQ as a phase fix

Cancellation looks like a lack of low end, so you boost 60 Hz on the DI and the amp track as if it were a tone problem. The result is louder and still hollow, with less headroom.

The second mistake is trusting your eyes. Lining up the transients on screen does not guarantee the low frequencies line up, because filters and amps shift their phase without moving the transient. Let your ears in mono decide, and if polarity and timing do not settle it, try a phase-rotation tool, which shifts phase without delaying the signal.

Takeaway

Fix the relationship before the tone

When two parts each sound full alone but thin together, work in order: check polarity, which is free and instant, then timing, then phase rotation. Reach for EQ only after the relationship is right.

The same order works wherever related signals meet: a kick and the sub under it, snare top and bottom mics, a guitar amp with two mics. For multi-mic drums, see the lesson on phase as timing.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. What does the polarity button do to a kick drum?
  2. Two copies of a sound play 1 ms apart. At which frequency do they first cancel?
  3. Your DI and amp tracks sound hollow together in mono. A polarity flip and a 0.3 ms nudge both help, but the lowest notes are still thin. What do you try next?

Sources

Show all 3
  • Senior, M. (2011). Mixing Secrets for the Small Studio. Focal Press.
  • Smith, J. O. (2007). Introduction to Digital Filters with Audio Applications. CCRMA, Stanford University. ccrma.stanford.edu/~jos/filters/
  • Smith, J. O. (2010). Physical Audio Signal Processing. W3K Publishing. ccrma.stanford.edu/~jos/pasp/

Next lesson · 15 of 44

What a 4:1 compression ratio doesThreshold, ratio and knee decide how much a compressor turns down before attack and release come in. Work out 4:1 by hand and you can predict any setting.

Previous: Stereo low end is a translation decision

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.