Skip to content

Saturation, clipping and limiting: three ways to get loud

All three lower your peaks so you can turn up. A saturator bends the wave, a clipper flattens it and a limiter turns it down, and each one sounds different.

Updated · 7 min read Lesson 30 of 44 in Mixing & Mastering

In short

  1. Saturation bends the wave gradually, hard clipping cuts it flat at a ceiling, and limiting turns the whole signal down for a short time.
  2. Saturation and clipping add harmonics and need oversampling; a limiter keeps the wave's shape but moves the level around each peak.
  3. Spread the work across small stages and judge each one at matched loudness, because normalization takes the extra level away anyway.
In this lesson (8)

Three tools, one word

Producers use "saturate it", "clip it" and "limit it" almost as if they meant the same thing. All three make a track louder at the same peak level, and none of them can be undone. They get there by doing different things to the waveform, and if you know which one you are reaching for, you can predict how the result will sound on every system.

Why it matters

Each one bends the wave differently

All three are nonlinear: they change the shape of the wave, where a fader only changes its size. They differ in how and when they act.

runs the signal through a smooth curve. Quiet parts pass almost unchanged, and louder parts are rounded off more and more as they approach the top of the curve. There is no corner anywhere.

Hard leaves everything below a ceiling exactly as it was and cuts everything above it flat. The change from untouched to flattened is instant.

Limiting is a with a very fast attack and a very high ratio. When the signal crosses the threshold, the turns the whole signal down, then turns it back up over its . The wave keeps its shape, but the samples around each peak are turned down along with it.

Figure 1. Input against output for two ways of holding a signal under a ceiling of 0.5. The hard clipper is perfectly straight until the ceiling, then flat. The soft clipper, a tanh curve, starts bending well below the ceiling and only approaches it.

Listen

Hear saturation add size, not volume

Bass and chords, or a real mix, through a waveshaper, level-matched so you hear the harmonics rather than a louder signal. Watch the spectrum fill in.

Loading demo…
100%

Start with your speakers or headphones low.

Soft clipping sits between the first two. Many clipper plugins have a control that rounds the corner, from fully hard to soft.

The science

Shape, harmonics and time

The classic saturation curve is the hyperbolic tangent. With a ceiling AA, as in the figure above:

y=Atanh⁡(xA)y = A \tanh\left( \frac{x}{A} \right)

For small inputs, tanh⁡\tanh is almost a straight line, so quiet material passes nearly clean. As the input grows, the output approaches AA without ever reaching it. A hard clipper is the limit of that idea:

y={Ax>Ax−A≤x≤A−Ax<−Ay = \begin{cases} A & x > A \\ x & -A \le x \le A \\ -A & x < -A \end{cases}

Any curve that bends the waveform creates at whole-number multiples of each note. A curve that treats the positive and negative halves the same way, like both of these, creates odd harmonics only: 3, 5, 7 times the . The hard clipper's corner makes those harmonics stronger and reach higher than the smooth curve does. A curve that treats the two halves differently, as some tube stages do, adds even harmonics as well. "Even sounds warm, odd sounds harsh" is a rough guide at best: real circuits produce a mix, and how that mix changes with level is much of what gives each one its character.

A limiter works in time instead. Its gain falls quickly when a peak arrives and recovers over the release, so it changes the level of everything around the peak and adds less harmonic content than a clipper doing the same job.

Figure 2. The same two hits through a hard clipper and through a fast limiter, both set to 0.5. The clipper flattens only the part of each cycle above the ceiling. The limiter keeps the shape of every cycle and turns the whole signal down, then takes time to recover, so the decay after each peak is turned down too.

Saturation and clipping share one digital problem. New harmonics can land above the , half the , and fold back down as . At 44.1 kHz, the 3rd harmonic of an 8 kHz tone sits at 24 kHz and folds to about 20 kHz; the 5th, at 40 kHz, folds to about 4 kHz. runs the process at a higher internal rate and filters off those harmonics before they can fold. I leave it off while writing and arranging, and turn it on for bounces and critical listening.

Try it

One loop, three tools

Step 3 needs a hard clipper with oversampling. If your DAW has none, a free one is easy to find.

0 of 6 steps done

Typically the saturator thickens the body and softens the edges, the clipper keeps the decay intact but adds bite to the peaks, and the limiter keeps the tone cleanest while the decay after loud hits dips and recovers.

Common mistake

One stage doing all the work

You ask the final limiter for all of the loudness. Push a -16 mix hard enough to read -8 LUFS and the limiter works constantly, grabbing every . On Spotify's default setting that master is then turned down 6 dB, to -14 LUFS. A master at -12 LUFS with 2 to 3 dB of limiting is turned down only 2 dB and plays at exactly the same loudness, with its drums intact.

The other mistake is reaching for the wrong tool: a limiter to add warmth to a vocal, or a clipper on a sustained bass line. Saturation is for tone and body, clipping for short peaks, limiting for the final ceiling.

Takeaway

Small amounts, in order

Spread the work. I use a clipper on my drum bus more often than a limiter there, because it shaves the tips of the transients without touching the body of the hit. Light saturation on single tracks, a couple of dB of clipping on the drum bus, and a final limiter doing 1 to 3 dB will usually sound fuller than one limiter doing 8. Set the limiter in mode for the delivery format, judge every stage at matched loudness, and check how the master sounds after , because that is what your listener hears. The lesson on clipping covers when it helps and what it costs.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. A signal sits at 0.25 into a soft clipper and a hard clipper, both with a ceiling of 0.5. Which one changes it?
  2. What does a limiter do that a clipper does not?
  3. In a 44.1 kHz session, a saturator creates a 5th harmonic at 40 kHz. Where does it land without oversampling?

Sources

Show all 4
  • Giannoulis, D., Massberg, M., & Reiss, J. D. (2012). Digital dynamic range compressor design: A tutorial and analysis. Journal of the Audio Engineering Society, 60(6), 399-408.
  • International Telecommunication Union. (2023). Recommendation ITU-R BS.1770-5: Algorithms to measure audio programme loudness and true-peak audio level. ITU. www.itu.int/rec/R-REC-BS.1770/
  • Reiss, J. D., & McPherson, A. (2014). Audio Effects: Theory, Implementation and Application. CRC Press.
  • Spotify for Artists. Loudness normalization on Spotify. support.spotify.com/artists/article/loudness-normalization/

Next lesson · 31 of 44

Stop treating LUFS like a targetA loudness meter tells you how loud a song measures, not how good it sounds. What integrated LUFS averages, and why chasing a reading flattens your drums.

Previous: Too clean can sound unfinished

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.