Skip to content

Swing explained without mystical language

Swing is one timing rule: every second note lands late. Here is the maths of the ratio, why tempo changes it, and how to stop parts from flamming.

Updated · 6 min read Lesson 12 of 20 in Arrangement & Groove

In short

  1. Swing delays every second subdivision by a share of the pair: 50 percent is straight and 66.7 percent is a triplet shuffle.
  2. The same percentage means fewer milliseconds at a faster tempo, and the short note can get too short to read as its own note.
  3. Set the tempo first, set swing by ear, and give every part that shares the off-beats the same setting.
In this lesson (8)

The swing slider myth

Producers talk about as if it were a secret. They swear by one drum machine's timing, or claim that one DAW has a warmer groove engine than another, and they drag a slider hunting for the number that will bring a loop to life.

There is no secret in it. Swing is one timing rule: every second subdivision lands late, so pairs of notes move long-short instead of evenly. Roger Linn, who designed the swing on his drum machines and the MPC, describes his version just as plainly: it delays the second 16th note within each 8th (Scarth and Linn, 2013). What makes swing feel right or wrong is how much you delay, at what tempo, and whether every part agrees.

Why it matters

One percentage, many timings

A swing setting is a share of the pair. At 50 percent both notes get equal time and the rhythm is straight. At 66.7 percent the first note takes two thirds of the pair and the second takes one third: a triplet shuffle. Most swing in beats lives between those two.

Because the setting is a share, the delay in milliseconds scales with tempo. At 58 percent, 16th-note swing delays each off-16th by 26.7 ms at 90 but only by 17.1 ms at 140 BPM. The shape stays the same while the absolute timing changes, which is why a preset that rolls at one tempo can feel stiff or cartoonish at another.

Figure 1. One bar of 16th-note swing. Only every second 16th moves, and it moves further as the setting rises. The kick and snare sit on positions that swing never touches.

Listen

Hear swing move the off-beats

One bar of drums. Drag the swing amount and watch every second 16th slide later while the downbeats stay put.

Loading demo…
100%

Start with your speakers or headphones low.

The science

The maths of long and short

Call the swing setting pp, the share of the pair given to the first note. The swing ratio compares the two durations:

r=TlongTshort=p1−pr = \frac{T_{\text{long}}}{T_{\text{short}}} = \frac{p}{1 - p}

Straight, 50 percent, gives 1:1. 58 percent gives about 1.4:1, and 66.7 percent gives 2:1. The second note arrives late by:

Δt=(p−0.5)×Tpair\Delta t = (p - 0.5) \times T_{\text{pair}}

The pair lasts Tpair=60 000/BPMT_{\text{pair}} = 60\,000 / \text{BPM} ms for 8th-note swing, and half that for 16th-note swing.

Players do not keep the ratio fixed. Friberg and Sundström (2002) measured the ride cymbal patterns of jazz drummers on commercial recordings and found that the swing ratio fell as tempo rose, from strongly long-short pairs at slow tempos to almost even 8ths at fast ones. At medium and fast tempos the short note stayed at roughly 100 ms, as if it had a floor. The same logic carries over to beats. Push 16th swing hard at a high tempo and the short note gets so short it stops reading as a note of its own.

Figure 2. How long the short 16th lasts at triplet swing, 66.7 percent, at four tempos. It shrinks as the tempo rises. The dim bar is the rough floor Friberg and Sundström (2002) found in jazz recordings, where players swung less at fast tempos to keep the short note near 100 ms.

Linn's own advice points the same way. He notes that 54 percent loosens a straight 16th beat without making it sound swung, and that a 90 BPM groove can feel looser at 62 percent than at a full triplet (Scarth and Linn, 2013).

Try it

The A/B swing test

0 of 6 steps done

At 100 BPM the 58 percent hats roll forward while the straight hats tick. At 140 BPM the same setting delays the off-beat by only 34.3 ms, and it sounds lighter.

Common mistake

Parts that disagree about the grid

Swing only moves the second note of each pair, so a kick on beats one and three does not move at all, and swinging it changes nothing. The real trouble starts when two parts share the off-beat positions with different swing. Swing the hats at 62 percent 16ths over a straight 16th bass line at 90 BPM, and every off-16th bass note lands 40 ms before the hat it should meet. That gap is wide enough to hear as two notes, so every off-beat flams. The same thing happens when a sample loop with its own swing plays under a programmed part with another.

Pick one swing amount and one resolution and apply it to every part that plays the off-beat positions. If you want one part straight, keep it off those positions.

Takeaway

Set swing by ear at the final tempo

Choose the tempo first, then the swing. Start straight and raise the amount in small steps while the full beat plays. Faster tracks usually want less, slower ones can carry more. Stop when the off-beats roll into the next beat, and back off when they start to bounce. Then give every part that shares those positions the same setting.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. At 100 BPM with 8th-note swing at 58 percent, how late does each off-beat 8th land?
  2. You swing the hats at 62 percent 16ths over a straight 16th bass line at 90 BPM. What do you hear?
  3. Why does a fast track usually need less swing than a slow one?

Sources

Show all 2

Next lesson · 13 of 20

Why groove lives between grid and bodyThe grid marks where a sound starts. Your body hears where its beat lands. Build the pocket from that gap, and correct for your own clapping bias.

Previous: Why tiny timing differences create human feel

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.