Skip to content

Make the chorus bigger without turning it up

A louder chorus runs into the limiter and the streaming volume knob. More parts, a higher register, brightness and width make it bigger at the same level.

Updated · 6 min read Lesson 9 of 10 in Songwriting

In short

  1. Choruses are usually a little louder than verses, but level is the one cue with a ceiling: once the limiter is working, extra decibels come out as lost punch.
  2. Streaming normalization moves the whole track by one gain, so the verse-to-chorus contrast survives while extra master loudness buys nothing.
  3. Match verse and chorus on a short-term meter, then build the lift from parts the verse held back, a higher register, brightness and width.
In this lesson (8)

The fader fight

You reach the chorus of your mix and it feels small. The drums do not hit and the vocal does not lift. So you grab the faders: the chorus tracks go up two decibels and the master works harder.

The chorus gets harsher instead of bigger. The limiter was already catching the peaks, so most of the extra level turns into gain reduction. The flatten, the cymbals smear, and the section you wanted to open up sounds squeezed. A bigger chorus usually comes from what the verse holds back and what the chorus adds, not from the fader.

Why it matters

Level is the lever with a ceiling

Choruses in pop really are louder than the sections around them, on average. A computational study of song sections from the Billboard charts found that chorus-like sections are louder, and also brighter, rougher, slightly higher in pitch and more varied in than other sections (Van Balen, Burgoyne, Wiering and Veltkamp, 2013). Level is one cue among several, and it is the only one with a hard limit.

Limiting and normalization cap it. On the master, once the limiter is catching the chorus peaks, every extra decibel comes out as more gain reduction and less punch. On playback, streaming services measure the integrated loudness of the whole track and apply one gain to all of it. Spotify, for example, aims at -14 by default and turns louder masters down (Spotify, n.d.). That gain moves the verse and the chorus together, so the gap between them survives. What does not survive is any loudness you gained by limiting the whole song harder. The listener hears the same level, minus your transients.

The other cues cost no : how many parts play, how high they sit, how bright they are and how wide they spread.

Figure 1. The goal of the experiment, sketched rather than measured. Loudness barely rises from verse to chorus, while the size the listener feels rises a lot, because several other cues step up at once.

The science

The ear judges the chorus against the verse

Hearing responds more to change than to steady states. A sound that carries on unchanged draws a smaller and smaller response, which is called , and a change in its features draws attention back. Huron (2006) adds that listeners build short-term expectations from the piece they are hearing, on top of what they know from a lifetime of music. The verse sets that short-term norm. A chorus that steps past it on several features at once is heard as an arrival, even when the meter barely moves.

That gives you four levers besides level:

  • Density. Parts the verse left out, such as a second guitar or a vocal double, enter on the chorus .
  • Register. The melody and the supporting parts move higher. Choruses in the Billboard study sat slightly higher in pitch.
  • Brightness. A verse kept a little dark makes an open top end in the chorus feel like light coming in.
  • Width. Parts kept near the centre in the verse spread out in the chorus.

Each one is small on its own. Together they make the chorus feel like a bigger room with more people in it, while the meter shows almost the same number.

Figure 2. Where the size comes from. Drums and the lead vocal hardly change. The chorus grows because parts the verse left out arrive: a second guitar in the pre-chorus, then a high synth and a vocal double on the chorus downbeat.

Try it

The level-matched chorus

0 of 8 steps done

With level matched, the new chorus should still feel like an arrival. If it does not, the verse is still giving too much away.

Common mistake

Spending everything in the verse

Wide pads, doubled vocals and bright synths play from the first bar, and the whole palette is spent early. When the chorus arrives, the only lever left is more of the same, which ends in and a limiter working flat out.

The second mistake is putting a stereo widener on the master to make the chorus feel big. A widener raises the side signal, and the side signal cancels when the mix is folded to mono. The parts that sounded huge drop back on a mono speaker. Put width on chosen parts, in the arrangement.

Takeaway

Build the chorus in the verse

A chorus is only big compared with something. If you want a wide chorus, keep the verse narrow. If you want it bright, keep the verse a little dark, and leave at least one part out of the verse so the chorus has something to add. Keep the level step modest, check it on a meter, and let the arrangement carry the rest.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. Spotify turns your master down by 4 dB. What happens to a chorus that was 3 dB louder than the verse?
  2. Your chorus already hits the master limiter hard. You push the chorus tracks up 2 dB. What mostly happens?
  3. In the experiment, why bring the chorus to within 1 LU of the verse before changing anything else?

Sources

Show all 3
  • Huron, D. (2006). Sweet Anticipation: Music and the Psychology of Expectation. MIT Press.
  • Spotify. (n.d.). Loudness normalization on Spotify. Spotify for Artists. support.spotify.com/us/artists/article/loudness-normalization/
  • Van Balen, J., Burgoyne, J. A., Wiering, F., & Veltkamp, R. C. (2013). An analysis of chorus features in popular song. In Proceedings of the 14th International Society for Music Information Retrieval Conference. doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1415624

Next lesson · 10 of 10

Keep the familiar chords, change the bassA common progression is a strength, not a cliché. Change the bass line and the timing of the changes, and the same four chords sound new.

Previous: Expensive choruses start with contrast

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.