Skip to content

Impact is not the same as level

A chorus can be loud and still not land. Impact comes from distance: hits above their body and sections above each other, which limiting closes.

Updated · 6 min read Lesson 35 of 44 in Mixing & Mastering

In short

  1. Impact is a change in level: a transient jumping out of its body, a chorus rising out of a verse.
  2. Limiting with makeup gain takes nearly a decibel of peak to average ratio for every decibel of gain reduction on the peaks.
  3. Judge every loudness move at matched level, because both the meter and your first impression favour the flatter version.
In this lesson (8)

The drop that did not land

You want the chorus to hit. You push the mix into the , raise the master fader, and the meters climb. When the chorus arrives it is loud, and it does not land. The verse was already almost as loud, the kick has turned into a thud, and the moment you built toward barely registers.

Level and impact are different things. Level is how much energy a meter averages. Impact is change: how far a hit jumps out of the sound around it, and how far a section rises above the one before.

Why it matters

The ear listens for change

Hearing is tuned to change. A sudden rise in level grabs attention, while a steady level, however high, fades into the background as you get used to it. A song uses that at two scales.

At the scale of one hit, a kick or snare has a short, sharp followed by a lower body. The transient holds a tiny share of the energy, but it is how you feel the strike. A limiter that takes the top off it so you can raise the rest leaves a hit that is louder on the meter and flatter to the ear.

Figure 1. Two hits from a simulation, one through a fast limiter with makeup gain back to the same peak. The limited hit is flat on top and its body sits higher, so it carries about 4.5 dB more energy and reads louder, while its front edge no longer stands out from the body.

At the scale of the arrangement, a chorus hits because it is louder and denser than the verse. Squash the verse up to nearly the same level and the chorus has nowhere to go.

Listen

Blind test: which one sounds better?

A synth loop or a real mix, played twice with one side 1 dB louder. Pick the one you prefer, then find out which was louder.

Loading demo…
100%

Start with your speakers or headphones low.

The science

Peak to average ratio

The distance between the transients and the average is the , also called the peak to average ratio, as in the lesson on loud masters after normalization:

PAR=20log⁡10(VpeakVRMS)\text{PAR} = 20 \log_{10}\left( \frac{V_{\text{peak}}}{V_{\text{RMS}}} \right)

A pure sine has a PAR of about 3 dB. A square wave, the shape heavy pushes toward, has 0 dB, because its peak and its RMS level are the same. Drum recordings sit well above the sine. Limit the peaks by a few decibels, add the same amount of makeup gain, and the peaks land where they were while the body, which holds most of the energy, rises almost the full amount. The PAR falls by close to the gain reduction.

That is why level-based thinking misleads you. Loudness meters average over 400 ms or longer and barely register a short transient, so they reward a change that removes the part of the sound that carries impact. The comparison is biased too: in a quick A/B, the louder version tends to sound better, even when it is the flatter one.

Try it

The matched-level hit test

0 of 6 steps done

At matched loudness the unlimited loop usually sounds like it hits harder: its transients stand further out, while the limited one has a softer front edge and a fuller gap between hits. The same test across a verse and chorus, for the lift between sections, is in the lesson on the final loudness push.

Common mistake

Making every part as loud as possible

You push every section to its maximum. When the verse is as loud as the chorus, the song loses its shape, and constant loudness gets tiring. Listeners turn it down.

The second mistake is a limiter or release that is too slow for the tempo. If the gain reduction has not recovered when the next hit arrives, that hit is turned down before it starts, and the groove flattens. Watch the gain reduction meter: it should fall back between hits.

Takeaway

Protect distances, not level

Build impact out of distances: transients above the body, chorus above verse. Use the limiter to catch what pokes out, not to close those gaps. Judge every loudness change at matched level, because the meter and your first impression both prefer the flatter version.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. You limit the peaks by 4 dB and add 4 dB of makeup gain. What happens to the peak to average ratio?
  2. Why does a chorus land harder when the verse before it is quieter?
  3. A heavily limited version wins your quick A/B. What should you check first?

Sources

Show all 3
  • European Broadcasting Union. (2023). Tech 3341: Loudness metering: 'EBU Mode' metering to supplement EBU R 128 loudness normalization. EBU. tech.ebu.ch/docs/tech/tech3341.pdf
  • Giannoulis, D., Massberg, M., & Reiss, J. D. (2012). Digital dynamic range compressor design: A tutorial and analysis. Journal of the Audio Engineering Society, 60(6), 399-408.
  • Katz, B. (2015). Mastering Audio: The Art and the Science (3rd ed.). Focal Press.

Next lesson · 36 of 44

The final loudness push steals emotionThe last few decibels of limiting raise the verse more than the chorus. How the final push closes the lift your song depends on, and where to stop.

Previous: Loud masters can shrink after matching

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.