In this lesson
Mud is often masking, not dirt
Mud usually comes from several parts piling up in the low mids and hiding each other. Find the pile-up and thin the parts that do not need it.
Updated · 6 min read · Lesson 4 of 44 in Mixing & Mastering
In short
- Mud is usually several parts each adding a little low-mid energy, which together mask everything near them.
- The ear sorts sound into bands only about 57 Hz wide near 300 Hz, and a loud low band also hides frequencies above it.
- Clear mud on the supporting parts with small, staggered cuts and high-pass filters instead of pushing the vocal.
In this lesson (8)
The buried vocal
Your lead vocal sounds muffled in the hook. You open an and boost 3 kHz, or you push the fader up 3 dB. The vocal pokes through, but now it sounds harsh and sits on top of the track, and the mix still feels thick and cloudy.
The vocal may be a great recording. What you are hearing is the arrangement around it: guitars, keys and a pad that each put a little energy in the same range. That build-up is , and it comes from parts that each sound fine on their own.
Why it matters
Mud is a sum
Solo any one of those parts and it sounds clean. The guitar has body, the keys have warmth, the pad fills the space. The trouble starts when they play together. Most melodic parts carry a lot of their energy between about 200 and 500 Hz, so three or four of them in the same section stack up there.
The stack does not sound like "too much 300 Hz" while you work on single tracks. It sounds like the vocal lost its words, the bass lost its shape and the whole mix got cloudy. So you reach for the vocal, the part that is suffering, instead of the parts that are causing it.
The science
Auditory bands and upward spread
The inner ear analyses sound with a bank of overlapping filters. Each one responds to a narrow range of frequencies, and two sounds that land in the same filter compete for it. Glasberg and Moore (1990) give the width of one of these filters, its equivalent rectangular bandwidth, as:
with in hertz. At 300 Hz that is about 57 Hz. A guitar peaking at 280 Hz and keys at 320 Hz sit inside one filter, and the ear cannot fully pull them apart. Within a band, the louder sound sets the masked threshold: the quieter one has to rise with it to stay audible (Fastl and Zwicker, 2007).
Masking also spreads, and unevenly. A loud sound hides frequencies above its own much more than frequencies below, and the spread widens as the masker gets louder (Wegel and Lane, 1924). A dense low-mid pile-up therefore veils more than the low mids. It blurs the lower part of the vocal and the attack of the bass notes too.
Hear the same principle in the demo below. The lead never changes level; only the pad around it does.
Listen
Free a lead from a crowded pad
A lead and a bright pad share the same range. Cut the pad or duck it under the lead and the lead comes forward without getting louder.
Start with your speakers or headphones low.
Try it
Find the pile-up and thin it
Use the densest section of the song, with every part playing.
0 of 6 steps done
With the cuts in, the vocal words and the bass notes come forward although neither fader moved. Bypass them and the cloud returns.
Common mistake
Fixing the victim
The common reflex is to fix the vocal: boost its presence or compress it hard. Compression keeps its level steady but does not move the competing energy, so a squashed vocal sitting over a thick pad still sounds pasted on top of the music. Presence boosts make it harsher without clearing the cloud underneath.
The opposite mistake is high-passing every backing track at 300 Hz. It takes the body below 300 Hz every time, but it reaches the mud only when the parts pile up that low. A 12 dB per octave filter at 300 Hz takes about half a decibel off 490 Hz, so a pile-up there stays while the warmth goes. Small, staggered cuts at the pile itself keep each part full in its own place, which a blanket cannot do.
Takeaway
Subtract before you add
When something is buried, look first for the parts that cover it, and take a little out of each where they overlap. A few decibels on three tracks clears more than six decibels on the one you want to hear.
Check the result in mono as well. Panning separates parts in stereo and hides some masking; in mono that help is gone, so it is the stricter test. If the vocal and bass still read clearly in mono, the low mids are under control.
Masking
One sound making another harder to hear, usually because they share frequencies at the same moment. A loud sound also masks what follows it for a short time (forward masking). The quieter sound is still there; the ear stops separating it.
High-pass filter
A filter that removes energy below a cutoff frequency and lets everything above it through.
3 questions
Check yourself
Sources
Show all 3Hide sources
- Fastl, H., & Zwicker, E. (2007). Psychoacoustics: Facts and Models (3rd ed.). Springer.
- Glasberg, B. R., & Moore, B. C. J. (1990). Derivation of auditory filter shapes from notched-noise data. Hearing Research, 47(1-2), 103-138.
- Wegel, R. L., & Lane, C. E. (1924). The auditory masking of one pure tone by another and its probable relation to the dynamics of the inner ear. Physical Review, 23, 266-285.
Next lesson · 5 of 44
Turning up a buried vocal rarely fixes itThe fader raises every band of the vocal at once. Whether the words come through depends on the vocal's lead over the competition in its own band.Previous: Reference tracks are for calibration, not imitation

Written by Virzy Guns
Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.