Skip to content

Small speakers need bass harmonics

A phone cannot play a 50 Hz sub, but it can play the harmonics above it, and the ear rebuilds the pitch from them. Design bass that survives small speakers.

Updated · 6 min read Lesson 7 of 10 in Sound Design

In short

  1. A small speaker cannot move enough air for deep bass: each octave down needs four times the cone movement for the same level.
  2. The ear hears the pitch of a bass note from its harmonics, even when the fundamental is missing.
  3. Keep the sub clean, add harmonics in parallel, and check through a high-pass filter and on a real phone.
In this lesson (8)

The disappearing bass line

In the studio the 808 shakes the desk and the kick hits you in the chest. You export, play the mix on your phone, and the bass line is gone. What is left is hi-hats, a dry vocal and a thin, hollow track.

Nothing broke in the export. A phone speaker produces very little deep bass, so a bass sound made almost entirely of its leaves it nothing to play. To make the bass translate, you have to give the speaker something it can play and give the ear enough to rebuild the rest.

Why it matters

The speaker cannot move enough air

At low frequencies, the sound pressure a small speaker makes depends on how much air its cone pushes and how fast that air accelerates:

p∝Sd x f2p \propto S_d \, x \, f^2

SdS_d is the cone area, xx how far the cone moves and ff the frequency. Each octave down needs four times the movement for the same level, so 55 Hz needs sixteen times the movement of 220 Hz. A phone speaker has a tiny cone that can only move a short distance, so in the deep bass it produces almost nothing. That conflict between bass output and speaker size is the starting point of Larsen and Aarts (2002).

Turning the sub up does not change that. The phone still cannot play it, and the extra level eats on every system that can. On a club rig the boosted sub swamps the mix. The fix is to put the identity of the bass where the phone works: in its .

The science

The missing fundamental

A pitched bass note is a fundamental f0f_0 plus harmonics at whole-number multiples of it:

fn=n f0f_n = n \, f_0

The ear does not need the fundamental to hear the pitch. Play 200, 300, 400 and 500 Hz together, with nothing at 100 Hz, and you hear a pitch of 100 Hz (Moore, 2012). The combined wave repeats every 10 ms, exactly as a 100 Hz tone does, and the auditory system takes the pitch from that repetition. The low-numbered harmonics carry it most strongly.

Figure 1. Thirty milliseconds of a 100 Hz tone above, and of four of its harmonics below, with no energy at 100 Hz. Both waves repeat every 10 ms, and that repetition rate is the pitch you hear.

Virtual bass processing for small speakers is built on this effect: it generates harmonics of the bass and plays them where the speaker works, so listeners hear bass pitch the speaker never produced (Larsen and Aarts, 2002, 2004). gets you there too. Drive a 50 Hz sub and it gains lines at multiples of 50 Hz, such as 100, 150 and 200 Hz, depending on the curve. The phone plays those, and the ear supplies the 50.

What you get is pitch and rhythm, not weight. A phone still cannot shake the room, and the harmonic version is a different sound from a deep sub. On small speakers, a bass you can follow beats a bass you cannot hear.

Figure 2. A 50 Hz sub after saturation, sketched. The first line is the sub itself, below anything a phone can play. The lines inside the shaded band are what the phone does play, and their spacing still says 50 Hz. The shaded band stands in for a small speaker's working range, which varies by device.

Listen

Hear saturation add size, not volume

Bass and chords, or a real mix, through a waveshaper, level-matched so you hear the harmonics rather than a louder signal. Watch the spectrum fill in.

Loading demo…
100%

Start with your speakers or headphones low.

Try it

The small-speaker bass test

Build a bass that keeps its melody when the low end is taken away.

0 of 7 steps done

Through the check filter and on the phone, the bass melody comes back although almost none of the fundamental gets through. On full-range speakers the bass sounds more defined without much more sub.

Common mistake

Boosting the sub

Boosting 40 Hz to make a quiet bass audible on small speakers does not work. The phone still cannot play that frequency, so nothing changes there, while every system that can play it gets a louder sub and a master that works harder.

The second mistake is saturating the whole bass, sub included, on one track. The deep end gets distorted along with everything else and turns woolly. Parallel saturation with a on the copy keeps the sub clean and puts the harmonics where they help.

Takeaway

Design the bass for both speakers

Write the bass for a phone and a club at the same time. Keep the sub clean and in mono for the systems that can play it. Add harmonics, through saturation, a wavefolder or a second an octave or two up, so the pitch survives where the sub cannot. Check through a high-pass on the master, then on a real phone, before you call the low end finished.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. A speaker plays 200, 300, 400 and 500 Hz, and nothing at 100 Hz. What pitch do you hear?
  2. Why can a phone not play a 50 Hz sub at a useful level?
  3. In the parallel setup, why high-pass the saturated copy?

Sources

Show all 3
  • Larsen, E., & Aarts, R. M. (2002). Reproducing low-pitched signals through small loudspeakers. Journal of the Audio Engineering Society, 50(3), 147-164.
  • Larsen, E., & Aarts, R. M. (2004). Audio Bandwidth Extension: Application of Psychoacoustics, Signal Processing and Loudspeaker Design. Wiley.
  • Moore, B. C. J. (2012). An Introduction to the Psychology of Hearing (6th ed.). Emerald.

Next lesson · 8 of 10

Too many layers make sounds smallerSimilar layers do not simply add. Offsets cut notches, detune makes the level swell and sag, and attacks smear. Layer by role instead of by copy.

Previous: Distortion adds size without more volume

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.