Skip to content

Keep the quiet detail a gate would cut

The fading ends of words and the soft starts of lines sit just above the noise, right where a gate acts. Clean the gaps by hand, then compress.

Updated · 6 min read Lesson 12 of 12 in Vocal Production

In short

  1. The quiet ends of words decay smoothly, so any gate threshold above the noise cuts them off mid-fade.
  2. Compression with makeup gain lifts quiet detail and room noise by the same amount, so clean the gaps before you compress.
  3. Lower gaps with clip gain and long fades, or use an expander with a limited range, instead of a hard gate.
In this lesson (8)

Clean, quiet and somehow cheaper

You edit a lead vocal until it is spotless. A gate on the channel makes every gap silent. Then the cleaned vocal sounds cheaper than the rough take did.

On vocals that sound expensive, you can hear the end of each word fade into the room, the small sounds of the mouth before a line and the soft way some lines start. Those quiet details are much of what makes a vocal sound close and handled with care, and they are the first thing an aggressive gate removes.

Why it matters

Quiet detail sits where the gate acts

A gate opens when the level rises above its threshold and closes when it falls back below. Room noise and headphone bleed sit at the bottom of a vocal track. The quiet detail sits just above them: the tail of a word as it decays, a soft consonant at the start of a line. To silence the gaps, you set the threshold above the noise, and every tail that decays through that threshold is cut at the moment it crosses, partway through its fade.

Near the threshold the gate also opens and closes on small changes in level. The room noise then appears and disappears with the voice, a pumping you hear most clearly on headphones.

Figure 1. The end of a word fading into room noise, drawn as level shapes. A gate set to silence the gap closes partway down the fade and cuts the rest of the word. Clip gain with a long fade lets the tail finish and then lowers the noise in the gap.

The science

Compression lifts detail and noise together

The reason producers reach for a gate is usually the that comes next. A compressor leaves everything below its threshold alone (Giannoulis, Massberg and Reiss, 2012), so makeup gain raises all of it by the same amount, quiet detail and noise alike.

Take peaks at -10 , a word tail at -40 dBFS and room noise at -60 dBFS. A 4:1 compressor with its threshold at -30 dBFS turns the peaks down to -25 dBFS: they were 20 dB over and come out 5 dB over, so the gain reduction is 15 dB. Makeup gain of 15 dB brings the peaks back to -10 dBFS. The tail and the noise were below the threshold, so they only get the makeup gain: the tail rises to -25 dBFS and the noise to -45 dBFS.

So the advice to compress a vocal to bring up its quiet detail is half right. It does bring the detail up relative to the peaks, and it brings the noise in the gaps up by exactly the same amount. and limiting later in the chain lift it again. That is why the order matters: clean the gaps first, then compress.

Figure 2. Peaks at -10 dBFS, a word tail at -40 and room noise at -60, through a 4:1 compressor with its threshold at -30 dBFS and 15 dB of makeup gain. The tail comes up 15 dB and so does the noise. The gap between them stays 20 dB, but both are now 15 dB closer to the peaks.

A gentler tool than a gate is a downward expander with a limited range (Reiss and McPherson, 2014). Below its threshold it turns the level down by a ratio, such as 1:2, but never by more than the range you set, such as 10 dB. A tail that crosses the threshold fades faster instead of stopping, and the noise drops without switching off.

Try it

Gate against hand clean-up

0 of 6 steps done

The gated version cuts the tails and the noise pumps in and out. The clip-gain version keeps every tail and leaves the gaps quiet without sounding dead. The expander lands between the two.

Common mistake

Compressing first, cleaning later

The usual order goes wrong in one of two ways. Either the vocal is gated hard and then compressed, and the compressor lifts the chopped edges and the switching noise along with everything else. Or the gaps are never cleaned, and every decibel of makeup gain on the vocal, the bus and the master lifts the room between the lines.

Clean up before the vocal chain, and the compressor has only the performance to work on.

Takeaway

Clean first, then compress

Do the clean-up by hand before any compression. Cut clicks and bleed in long gaps, lower the rest of each gap with , and use fades long enough to let the tails finish. Where a soft word or a quiet ending gets lost in the mix, raise it with clip gain instead of adding more compression. Leave a little room tone in the gaps, so the vocal sounds quieter between lines without sounding switched off.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. Peaks at -10 dBFS, room noise at -60. A 4:1 compressor at -30 dBFS with 15 dB of makeup gain. Where does the room noise end up?
  2. Why does a gate cut off the end of a long word?
  3. What does a downward expander with a 10 dB range do differently from a gate?

Sources

Show all 2
  • Giannoulis, D., Massberg, M., & Reiss, J. D. (2012). Digital dynamic range compressor design: A tutorial and analysis. Journal of the Audio Engineering Society, 60(6), 399-408.
  • Reiss, J. D., & McPherson, A. (2014). Audio Effects: Theory, Implementation and Application. CRC Press.

Lesson 12 of 12

You reached the end of Vocal Production

That was the last of 12 lessons in this path. The next path is Mixing & Mastering, 44 lessons.

Mixing & Mastering, lesson 1Why louder is not always bigger in a mixA plugin that adds one decibel sounds like an upgrade even when it changes nothing else. Level-match every A/B so you keep only the moves that help.

Back to the Vocal Production pathAll pathsAll lessons

Previous: Ad-libs are arrangement moves

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.