Skip to content

A hook needs a familiar shape and one odd turn

Catchy melodies tend to follow a common shape with something unusual inside it. How repetition builds a hook, when it wears out, and how one chord change renews it.

Updated · 6 min read Lesson 6 of 14 in Music Psychology

In short

  1. Tunes that get stuck in people's heads tend to have a common overall contour, with less usual rises and falls between its high and low points.
  2. Repetition makes a hook easy to predict and sing, but close listening to the same thing over and over eventually lowers liking.
  3. Repeat the melody exactly and change the harmony under its last note, so the familiar line ends somewhere new.
In this lesson (8)

The loop that wears out by bar sixteen

You write a hook and repeat the same four-bar vocal phrase over the same chords four times in a row. You expect the repetition to make it stick. You play it for a friend, and by the third pass they have stopped listening. The hook is easy to remember, and it already sounds used up.

Nearly every hook repeats. This one wears out because nothing about the repeat changes, so after the second pass the listener has nothing left to predict.

Why it matters

A familiar shape with something odd inside

Jakubowski and colleagues (2017) compared 100 songs people often reported getting stuck in their heads with 100 matched songs that were never named. The earworms tended to have a more common overall contour, often a rise followed by a fall, and less common slopes between its high and low points: how steeply the line climbs or falls from one turning point to the next. They were also faster on average. A catchy line seems to combine a shape the ear already knows with one detail it does not expect.

Repetition then does its own work. Margulis (2014) argues that repetition changes how music is heard: on each pass, attention moves to different details, and the listener starts to anticipate the line well enough to sing along. That is part of what makes a chorus feel like it belongs to the listener.

Figure 1. The shape Szpunar, Schellenberg and Pliner (2004) reported for their most realistic music. Heard in the background, liking kept rising with exposure. Heard with full attention, it rose and then fell. A sketch of the shape, not their data.

There is a limit. Szpunar, Schellenberg and Pliner (2004) played music to listeners many times. When they heard it in the background, liking kept rising with exposure. When they listened with full attention, liking rose over the first few plays and then fell. A hook that never changes is heard closely, again and again, by exactly the people you want to keep.

The science

Repeat the line, move the ground

The simplest way to renew a repeated melody is to keep it exactly the same and change what sits under it. The melody stays predictable, and the harmony gives the listener something new to hear it against.

The is the classic version. After a dominant chord (V), the ear expects the home chord (I). Moving to the minor chord on the sixth degree (vi) instead keeps the music close to home, because vi shares two notes with I, while denying the full resolution. Huron (2006) uses the deceptive as an example of an expectation the ear holds on every hearing, even when the listener knows the song.

In C major, the melody can end on a C over C major the first time and on the same C over A minor the second time. A minor contains C, so the note still fits, but the phrase no longer sounds finished.

Figure 2. The same four-bar melody over two harmonizations. The first pass resolves from V to I and the tension drains. The second moves from V to vi, a deceptive cadence: the melody ends on the same note, but the harmony stays open.

Try it

Same melody, new last chord

Use a piano or synth patch and a MIDI editor.

0 of 6 steps done

The A minor ending should make the second pass pull forward into whatever comes next, while the melody stays exactly as the listener learned it. Without the leap in bar 2, listen for whether the line loses the one turn that set it apart.

Common mistake

Copy and paste as the arrangement

Pasting the same chorus block four times with nothing changed feels like a finished arrangement. Each pass is a perfect copy of the last, and an attentive listener hears it as a loop rather than a chorus. Change the harmony, the bass line or the arrangement on later passes, and keep the melody itself.

The opposite mistake is putting the variation in the melody. A hook should be simple enough to hum after one hearing. If you rewrite the tune on every pass, nothing gets learned. Let the chords and the production carry the change.

Takeaway

Keep the tune, change the ground

Build the hook from a shape the ear knows and give it one turn it does not expect. Repeat that line exactly, because repetition is how it gets learned. Then change what is underneath: end one pass on vi, move the bass, add or strip a layer. If the hook still sounds fresh on the fourth pass, keep it. If it sounds like a loop, change the last chord before you change the melody.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. People forget your hook after one play. Which rewrite brings it closer to the earworms Jakubowski and colleagues (2017) analysed?
  2. A melody ends on C in C major. Which change under that last note keeps the note and leaves the phrase open?
  3. After a week of looping your chorus with full attention you are sick of it, while the client, who mostly heard it under their video edit, likes it more each time. What explains the split?

Sources

Show all 4
  • Huron, D. (2006). Sweet Anticipation: Music and the Psychology of Expectation. MIT Press.
  • Jakubowski, K., Finkel, S., Stewart, L., & Müllensiefen, D. (2017). Dissecting an earworm: Melodic features and song popularity predict involuntary musical imagery. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts, 11(2), 122-135.
  • Margulis, E. H. (2014). On Repeat: How Music Plays the Mind. Oxford University Press.
  • Szpunar, K. K., Schellenberg, E. G., & Pliner, P. (2004). Liking and memory for musical stimuli as a function of exposure. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 30(2), 370-381.

Next lesson · 7 of 14

Why a song grows on you with repeated playsLiking for a new track often climbs over everyday plays, and remembering a hook is a separate thing from liking it. What the studies found, and how to test a demo.

Previous: A chord's mood depends on how you get there

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.