Skip to content

Clipping can work. It can also cost you

A clipper can buy a decibel or two of drum headroom almost for free. Push it on a full mix and the bass starts distorting everything that sits on top of it.

Updated · 6 min read Lesson 39 of 44 in Mixing & Mastering

In short

  1. A clipper flattens only what crosses its ceiling, so shaving the tips of short drum transients can buy headroom you barely hear.
  2. On a full mix the bass crosses the ceiling first, and clipping it adds harmonics plus intermodulation sidebands that belong to no note.
  3. Clip a dB or two on short peaks, oversample, and level-match every comparison.
In this lesson (8)

Free headroom, until it is not

You want louder drums without the pumping, and you read that engineers put a clipper before the limiter. You add one, drive it, and the meter rises without the limiter working harder. Then you listen closely: the kick has lost weight, the low end sounds woolly, and the hi-hats have a fizzy edge.

is a real tool, and you will find it on plenty of loud records. It is also distortion, every single time. The only question is whether you can hear it.

Why it matters

What a clipper does to the waveform

A hard clipper lets everything below its ceiling through untouched and flattens anything above it. On a drum bus, only the tips of the loudest cross the ceiling, for a millisecond or two. Shave 1 or 2 dB off those tips and you can raise the whole bus by the same amount before the peaks reach where they were. The limiter after it has less to do.

The cost is new frequency content. A flattened peak is a sharper shape than the wave it came from, and sharp shapes contain . Short drum transients hide a lot of that. A sustained bass note does not, and in a full mix the bass and kick carry most of the peak level, so on a mix bus they are what reach the ceiling first.

Figure 1. On its own, a bass note driven into a hard clip loses its crests. With a quieter high note on top, the clipper also wipes out the high note at every bass crest, twice per bass cycle. That on and off pattern is intermodulation.

Listen

Hear saturation add size, not volume

Bass and chords, or a real mix, through a waveshaper, level-matched so you hear the harmonics rather than a louder signal. Watch the spectrum fill in.

Loading demo…
100%

Start with your speakers or headphones low.

The science

Harmonics and intermodulation

A hard clipper passes everything below its ceiling untouched and holds everything above it at the ceiling, as drawn in the lesson on saturation, clipping and limiting. Because it treats positive and negative peaks the same way, a clipped sine gains odd harmonics only: 3, 5, 7 times the and up. The harder you drive it, the closer the wave gets to a square, whose peak and RMS level are equal, and the stronger those harmonics become. Clipping trades peak for density.

When several sounds are clipped together, the output also contains : new frequencies at sums and differences of the inputs. With a big bass note under a quieter tone, the bass decides when the tone gets flattened, twice per bass cycle, and that shows up as sidebands either side of the tone. In a quick test, an 80 Hz note with a quieter 1 kHz tone on top, driven about 3 dB into a hard clip, produced sidebands at 840 and 1160 Hz only a few decibels below the tone. Those frequencies belong to neither note. That is why a clipped mix bus can sound rough and muddy when the clipped drum bus sounded clean.

Figure 2. What came out when an 80 Hz note and a quieter 1 kHz tone were hard-clipped together. Besides the bass's own 3rd harmonic, sidebands appear at 840 and 1160 Hz: the tone plus and minus twice the bass frequency. Neither belongs to either note.

Try it

Find your clipping point

You need a clipper with . Some stock clippers have no oversampling switch, so check yours before you start.

0 of 6 steps done

On drums, 1 dB is often hard to hear and 6 dB softens the crack. On the full mix the distortion shows up sooner, in the bass and the vocal, because the bass is what crosses the ceiling.

Common mistake

Clipping as a volume knob

You drive a clipper until the track is loud enough, as if it were a fader. On a mix bus the distortion builds in the low end first, and the intermodulation roughens everything the bass sits under.

The other mistake is clipping without oversampling. A clipper's harmonics extend far above the , and without oversampling they fold back down as tones unrelated to the music. Turn oversampling on, or test the plugin with a sine and an analyzer as described in the lesson on aliasing.

Takeaway

Shave tips, not bodies

Use a clipper where the material is made of short peaks, like a drum bus, and keep it to a dB or two before the limiter. On a mix bus, clip less than you think, listen to the bass and the vocal rather than the drums, and level-match every comparison. Keep oversampling on.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. Why does a drum bus usually take clipping better than a full mix?
  2. A symmetric hard clipper is fed a pure sine at 100 Hz. Which new frequencies appear?
  3. An 80 Hz bass and a 1 kHz tone are clipped together. Where do the strongest sidebands land?

Sources

Show the source
  • Reiss, J. D., & McPherson, A. (2014). Audio Effects: Theory, Implementation and Application. CRC Press.

Next lesson · 40 of 44

True peak bites after encodingA master can read -0.1 dBFS and still clip on a phone. Why the wave between samples and the lossy encode both peak higher, and which ceiling to set.

Previous: Heavy limiting changes the tone of a master

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.