In this lesson
Keep the familiar chords, change the bass
A common progression is a strength, not a cliché. Change the bass line and the timing of the changes, and the same four chords sound new.
Updated · 5 min read · Lesson 10 of 10 in Songwriting
In short
- A familiar progression is easy to predict, which leaves the listener's attention free for the melody and the words.
- Freshness can come from the bass line and the timing of the changes while the chords themselves stay the same.
- Try an inversion such as G/B for a stepwise bass, and push chord changes an eighth note before the bar line.
In this lesson (8)
Two hours replacing four good chords
You sit down to write a song and play a simple four-chord progression: I, V, vi, IV. It sounds stable and immediately familiar.
Then a voice in your head says it is too simple. It is one of the most used progressions in pop, so you feel lazy for using it. You spend the next two hours replacing the chords with modal borrowings and minor ninths.
When you play it back, the groove is gone. The song feels cold and hard to follow. By trying to make the progression unique, you have taken away the thing that made it easy to listen to.
Why it matters
The frame the melody stands on
Listeners do not need complex harmony to connect with a song. A familiar progression lets them predict where the song is going, which leaves their attention free for the melody and the words.
The opposite costs them effort. Listeners track the key across several chords at once, and in Krumhansl and Kessler's experiments shifts to distant keys took longer to register than shifts to close ones (Krumhansl and Kessler, 1982). A progression that keeps wandering asks the listener to keep reorienting, and that attention comes out of the melody's share.
Too predictable has its own cost: the song can sound generic. The usual answer is to present the familiar chords in a new way.
The science
Two kinds of expectation
Huron (2006) separates schematic expectations, built from everything you have heard in a style, from veridical expectations, your memory of one particular song. I, V, vi, IV matches a strong schema, so listeners predict it easily, and accurate predictions tend to feel good.
Freshness can come from a lower level of detail while the schema holds. Which note is in the bass, and exactly when the chord changes, are separate predictions. Change them and the listener gets small surprises that still make sense, because the progression underneath is the one they expected. Huron also argues that schematic expectations keep working even when you know a song well, which is part of why a well-placed surprise can survive many hearings.
The most useful tool is the : the same chord with a note other than the root in the bass. G/B means a G major chord with B as the lowest note. In C, G/B, Am, F, the bass falls by step from C to B to A, then drops to F. The chords have not changed, but the bass is now a melody. Moving each voice by the smallest available step between chords is called smooth .
The second tool is timing. Moving a chord change an eighth note ahead of the bar line, so it ties over into the bar, is called a push. It makes the harmony lean forward against the beat without changing a single chord.
Try it
The bass mutation pass
0 of 6 steps done
The chords are identical, but the new loop moves differently: the bass sings a line of its own and the pushes make each change lean into the next bar.
Common mistake
The extension overload
You load a simple pop song with jazz extensions. Major sevenths and minor ninths can sound beautiful, but voiced low they muddy the bass register and can clash with the vocal. A useful rule of thumb from arranging: close intervals such as seconds and thirds sound clear high up and muddy low down. Keep extensions in the upper part of the voicing and the bass on roots, fifths or inversions.
The second mistake is believing that simple chords mean lazy writing. A simple progression is often the professional choice because it gives the vocal room.
Takeaway
Taste is in the angle
Taste is often in the angle, not the raw material. Keep your harmony simple and let the bass line, the rhythm of the changes and the vocal melody do the fresh work. Before you change a chord, try changing its bass note or the moment it arrives.
3 questions
Check yourself
Sources
Show all 2Hide sources
- Huron, D. (2006). Sweet Anticipation: Music and the Psychology of Expectation. MIT Press.
- Krumhansl, C. L., & Kessler, E. J. (1982). Tracing the dynamic changes in perceived tonal organization in a spatial representation of musical keys. Psychological Review, 89(4), 334-368.
Lesson 10 of 10
You reached the end of Songwriting
That was the last of 10 lessons in this path. The next path is Arrangement & Groove, 20 lessons.
Arrangement & Groove, lesson 1Draw the energy curve before you mixWhen verse and chorus are equally full, no master chain can make the chorus bigger. Rate each section, draw the curve, and fix it in the arrangement.
Written by Virzy Guns
Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.