In this lesson
Why finishing needs its own session
Writing asks you to accept rough sounds. Finishing asks you to judge them. Try to do both in the same minute and the song stays a four-bar loop.
Updated · 5 min read · Lesson 9 of 10 in Producer Mindset
In short
- Creative work cycles between making rough material and judging it, and every switch between the two costs time and accuracy.
- In a writing session, judge only keep or replace. In a finishing session, write nothing new.
- Finish in passes: listen once, write three fixes, make only those and bounce.
In this lesson (8)
The four-bar loop that never grows
You are writing a new track. There is a good four-bar chord progression on a pad and a basic drum loop. Instead of writing the verse melody, you stop. You open an , solo the kick and spend twenty minutes sweeping a narrow band to find the mud. Then you put a delay on the pad, tweak the feedback and go looking for a vocal sample. Two hours later you are still listening to the same four bars, the spark is gone and the project joins the folder of unfinished beats.
You were doing two jobs at once. Making new material and finishing it ask for different things from you, and doing both in the same minute keeps a song stuck in the loop.
Why it matters
Two jobs that pull against each other
Generating ideas works best when you accept rough sounds so you can keep moving. Placeholder drums and a preset pad are fine, because the question is whether the part is worth having. Finishing asks the opposite: a critical ear that makes hard calls about balance, structure and detail.
When you mix both, each interrupts the other. You polish eight bars that may not survive the arrangement, and you lose the ideas that would have told you what the arrangement is. A finished song is a trail of decisions made in order: what the parts are, then where they go, then how they sound.
The science
Generate, explore, and pay for every switch
Creativity researchers describe the same two jobs. In the Geneplore model, Finke, Ward and Smith (1992) split creative thinking into a generative phase, which produces rough, half-formed structures, and an exploratory phase, which examines them and works out what they could become. The phases alternate, and both are needed.
Brain imaging points the same way. Ellamil and colleagues (2012) scanned art students while they designed book covers, alternating between generating ideas and evaluating them. Generating leaned on regions in the medial temporal lobe, which support memory retrieval. Evaluating recruited executive and default network regions together. The two modes use the brain differently, so moving between them is a real change of gear.
Changing gear has a price. In task-switching experiments, people are slower and make more errors right after a switch, and preparing in advance reduces that cost without removing it (Monsell, 2003). In a lab the cost is measured on simple tasks. In a writing session it shows up as the verse melody you were about to find before you opened the EQ.
The practical answer is to batch the modes. Write in one pass, where the only judgment is keep or replace. Finish in another, where new parts are off the table.
Try it
The three-fix pass
Use a project that already runs from intro to outro but feels unfinished.
0 of 6 steps done
Each pass ends with a complete, better bounce. Over a few passes the fixes on your list get smaller. When the three fixes are changes you can no longer pick in a blind, level-matched comparison, the song is finished.
Common mistake
Mixing while writing
It usually looks like loading and EQs on every channel while you are still looking for the bass line. Every processed sound feels like a commitment, and you start defending parts because of the time you spent on them.
Placeholder sounds and a closed mixer are the fastest way to get the skeleton of a song down. Shape a sound during writing only when the sound itself is the idea, such as a bass patch the whole song is built around.
Takeaway
Define the finish line before you open the session
Before you open a project, decide which kind of session it is and write it in the project notes. In a writing session, keep going even when a sound is rough. In a finishing session, do not write new parts. Decide in advance what finished means for this song, for example "three fixes in a row that I cannot hear blind", and stop when you get there.
Compressor
A processor that turns a signal down once it goes above a threshold. The ratio sets how much: at 4:1, every 4 dB over the threshold comes out as 1 dB over.
3 questions
Check yourself
Sources
Show all 3Hide sources
- Ellamil, M., Dobson, C., Beeman, M., & Christoff, K. (2012). Evaluative and generative modes of thought during the creative process. NeuroImage, 59, 1783-1794.
- Finke, R. A., Ward, T. B., & Smith, S. M. (1992). Creative Cognition: Theory, Research, and Applications. MIT Press.
- Monsell, S. (2003). Task switching. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 7(3), 134-140.
Next lesson · 10 of 10
Protect momentum while you writeStopping to EQ a snare in the middle of an idea can cost you the chorus. Write the problem down in one line, keep writing and fix the list in a separate pass.
Written by Virzy Guns
Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.