Skip to content

Mono reveals what stereo hides

Width made with delay, polarity or side boosts can thin out or vanish when a phone or a club folds your mix to one channel. Toggle mono while you mix to catch it.

Updated · 6 min read Lesson 11 of 44 in Mixing & Mastering

In short

  1. Phones, smart speakers and many venue systems add left and right together, and some width tricks do not survive the sum.
  2. A phase difference between the channels costs 3 dB in mono at 90 degrees and everything at 180, and a delay makes that loss change with frequency.
  3. Toggle mono while you mix, keep the low end centred, and build width from different sources rather than from copies.
In this lesson (8)

The width that disappears

Your mix sounds huge on the studio monitors. The synths are spread wide, the backing vocals wrap around your head, and the effects build a big space. Then you play it on a phone, a small Bluetooth speaker or a club system, and the energy drains away. The lead synth goes thin, the backing vocals vanish and the chorus loses its lift.

On those systems the left and right channels are often added together into one. If part of your width was built from differences between the channels that cancel when they are added, that part of the mix goes with it.

Why it matters

Width tricks pay a price in mono

Plenty of everyday playback is mono: a single phone speaker, most smart speakers, and many venue and club rigs. A mix that holds up there is a mix that translates. A mix that relies on width tricks can sound like a different song.

Not every trick fails in the same way. A widener that boosts the side signal loses that boost completely, because the side signal is the difference between the channels and the sum removes it. A short delay on one side, the Haas trick, turns into a . A flip or a shift between the channels cancels part or all of the sound. Hear the last two on a pluck while the kick, bass and snare stay in the middle:

Listen

Fold the mix to mono

Kick, bass and snare in the middle, and a pluck made wide with a stereo trick. Switch to mono and hear which one survives.

Loading demo…
100%

Start with your speakers or headphones low.

The science

What happens in the sum

A simple mono fold adds the channels and halves the result:

Smono(t)=12(SL(t)+SR(t))S_{\text{mono}}(t) = \frac{1}{2} \left( S_L(t) + S_R(t) \right)

Take one frequency with amplitude AA in both channels, and shift the right channel by an angle θ\theta. The mono amplitude is then:

Amono=Acos⁡(θ2)A_{\text{mono}} = A \cos\left(\frac{\theta}{2}\right)

At 0 degrees nothing is lost. At 90 degrees the level drops by 3 dB, at 120 degrees by 6 dB, and at 180 degrees, a flipped polarity, the frequency cancels completely.

Figure 1. How loud one frequency is after the mono sum when the right channel is shifted against the left, computed from A cos(θ/2). Small offsets cost little. At 90 degrees you lose 3 dB, at 120 you lose 6, and at 180 the frequency is gone.

A delay makes it worse, because the same delay is a different phase shift at every frequency: θ=360∘×f×τ\theta = 360^\circ \times f \times \tau. Wherever θ\theta reaches 180 degrees, or 540, or any odd multiple, the two copies cancel. The notches fall at:

fnotch=2k+12τ,k=0,1,2,…f_{\text{notch}} = \frac{2k + 1}{2\tau}, \quad k = 0, 1, 2, \dots

A 12 ms delay puts the first notch at 42 Hz and the rest every 83 Hz above it. This regular row of notches is a comb filter (Smith, 2010), and it is the hollow, phasey sound a Haas-widened part takes on in mono.

Figure 2. A part widened with a 12 ms delay on one side, folded to mono. The first cancellation lands at 42 Hz and the next ones follow every 83 Hz, all the way up the spectrum. That row of notches is the hollow, phasey sound.

Try it

A mono check routine

Set this up once and use it throughout the mix.

0 of 6 steps done

The centre parts stay put when you toggle. The ones that thin out or shift tone are your width tricks, and now you know which ones cost too much.

Common mistake

Widening the whole master

You put a stereo imager on the master bus and push the width up. It feels bigger in the studio, but it raises the side signal across the whole spectrum, and everything you gain disappears in mono while the centre image gets weaker in stereo.

Another mistake is giving the low end width. The kick and the bass carry most of a mix's energy, and a low end that partly cancels in mono loses its weight on exactly the systems where it matters. Keep everything below roughly 120 Hz centred.

Takeaway

Width that survives the fold

Lasting width comes from different sources, not from copies of one. Record two takes of a guitar part and pan them left and right. The natural differences in timing and tone make them sound wide in stereo, and because they are not copies they do not cancel when added. They simply add.

Check your mix on a single speaker at low volume before you call it done. If the vocal, the groove and the hook still come through, the mix will translate. Width is the extra on top.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. The right channel of a synth is 90 degrees behind the left at one frequency. What happens to that frequency in mono?
  2. One side of a pluck is delayed by 12 ms for width. Why does it sound hollow in mono?
  3. A wide pad was made with a mid-side widener that boosts the side signal. What happens to the boost in mono?

Sources

Show all 2
  • Senior, M. (2011). Mixing Secrets for the Small Studio. Focal Press.
  • Smith, J. O. (2010). Physical Audio Signal Processing. W3K Publishing. ccrma.stanford.edu/~jos/pasp/

Next lesson · 12 of 44

Mid/side widening moves the centre tooA side boost raises every part that is not dead centre, by up to 4 dB at +6 dB of side. It changes your balance and your panning, and mono never hears it.

Previous: Depth needs contrast to exist

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.