Skip to content

Lyric rhythm carries the feeling

A lyric that fights the beat sounds forced, however good the words. Put stresses on strong beats, open vowels on high notes and vowels on the grid.

Updated · 6 min read Lesson 5 of 10 in Songwriting

In short

  1. Listeners hear emotion in a voice from its tempo, loudness and pitch, the same cues music uses, apart from what the words mean.
  2. Put stressed syllables on strong beats, and line up the start of the vowel, not the first consonant, with the grid.
  3. Give the highest notes open vowels such as "ah", because closed vowels like "ee" and "oo" have to be opened up there.
In this lesson (8)

The clunky message

You write a lyric line with a deep, poetic message. It looks beautiful on paper and the meaning is clear.

When you sing it over the beat, the groove disappears. The singer stumbles over the consonants and the rhythm feels clunky. You try to fix it in the mix with timing edits and compression, but the vocal still sounds forced. The words are right and the rhythm of the words is wrong, and the rhythm is what the listener feels first.

Why it matters

The voice carries feeling apart from the words

Juslin and Laukka (2003) reviewed 104 studies of emotion in the voice and 41 studies of emotion in music performance. In both, listeners recognized the intended emotions well above chance, and the acoustic cues that signalled each emotion were similar: tempo, loudness, pitch level and movement, and . Much of what a sung line feels like is carried by how it is delivered, separately from what the words say.

In a session, two things go wrong. Lines packed with consonant clusters, or with closed vowels on the high notes, make the singer work, and the effort shows as throat tension and late timing. And lines whose stressed syllables fall in weak positions sound wrong even to a listener who could not say why. Lyric-writing teachers such as Pattison (2009) treat this fit between spoken stress and musical stress as part of : every element of a song working together to support what it says.

The science

Stress, the moment a syllable lands, and vowels

Stress meets metre. In English, some syllables are stressed: louder, longer and often higher. Palmer and Kelly (1992) analysed songs and found that composers tend to put stressed syllables on strong metrical positions. When they tested singers, syllables were sung longer when they were stressed in the language or placed on a strong beat. When the two pull in different directions, the singer has to favour one of them, and the line tends to sound awkward.

Figure 1. The phrase "(I) can't forget you tonight" in one bar. Tall bars are stressed syllables. Matched, can't, get and night fall on beats. Mismatched, the same rhythm moved an 8th note later puts for, you and to on the beats and pushes the stresses between them.

A syllable lands at its vowel. The moment a syllable seems to happen is not the moment its sound starts. Morton, Marcus and Frankish (1976) called this moment the , or P-centre, and it sits near the start of the vowel. A word like "street" begins with a soft "str" that comes before the vowel. If you line the start of the word up with the beat, the vowel lands late and the word drags.

Figure 2. The level of the word "street" over time. The soft "str" comes before the vowel. Put the start of the word on the beat and the vowel lands after it, so the word sounds late. Put the vowel on the beat and it sounds on time.

Vowels and high notes. Every vowel has resonances shaped by the mouth and throat, its , and the first formant sits at a different frequency for each vowel. Peterson and Barney (1952) measured averages for adult men of about 270 Hz for "ee", 300 Hz for "oo" and 730 Hz for "ah". When the sung note rises above a vowel's first formant, singers tend to open the jaw to raise that formant, which changes the vowel (Sundberg, 1987). Open vowels like "ah" have room at the top of a chorus. Closed vowels like "ee" and "oo" get modified or sound pinched.

Figure 3. First formant of three vowels, averages for adult men (Peterson and Barney, 1952), against a sung A4 at 440 Hz. The note sits above the first formant of "ee" and "oo", so singers have to open those vowels; "ah" still has room. Women's averages are higher, but the order is the same.

Try it

The spoken rhythm test

0 of 7 steps done

The words should now sit in the beat with less effort. The vowel-aligned edit sounds on time, while the consonant-aligned one drags behind the drums.

Common mistake

The literal obsession

Some lines survive every edit because of what they literally say. Songwriters hold on to a line because it really happened, even when the words are hard to sing cleanly. A true line that cannot be sung well loses to a slightly different line that can.

The second mistake is putting closed vowels on the highest notes of the chorus. The singer has to open "ee" or "oo" up there anyway, so the word either changes shape or comes out thin and tense. Choose the word for the vowel the note needs.

Takeaway

The mouth is a drum

The mouth is a drum when the lyric is honest. Write the rhythm of the line before you polish the words. Speak it over the beat and check the stresses, then give the high notes open vowels. When you edit, line up vowels, not consonants. If a word is hard to sing or breaks the groove, change it. If the rhythm of the words moves the body, the listener will stay to hear the story.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. You edit the word "street" so the "s" starts exactly on the snare. Why does it sound late?
  2. Which setting gives "come back" the most natural stress?
  3. A male singer has to hold an A4 at the top of the chorus. Which vowel gives him the most room?

Sources

Show all 6
  • Juslin, P. N., & Laukka, P. (2003). Communication of emotions in vocal expression and music performance: Different channels, same code? Psychological Bulletin, 129(5), 770-814.
  • Morton, J., Marcus, S., & Frankish, C. (1976). Perceptual centers (P-centers). Psychological Review, 83(5), 405-408.
  • Palmer, C., & Kelly, M. H. (1992). Linguistic prosody and musical meter in song. Journal of Memory and Language, 31(4), 525-542.
  • Pattison, P. (2009). Writing Better Lyrics (2nd ed.). Writer's Digest Books.
  • Peterson, G. E., & Barney, H. L. (1952). Control methods used in a study of the vowels. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 24(2), 175-184.
  • Sundberg, J. (1987). The Science of the Singing Voice. Northern Illinois University Press.

Next lesson · 6 of 10

The verse is stealing the chorusA verse that ends on the home chord with its story told leaves the chorus nothing to do. Leave it open and the chorus becomes the answer.

Previous: Repetition sticks when one detail changes

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.