Skip to content

Comp vocals in phrases, not syllables

A comp stitched word by word can be flawless and still feel cold. Build it from whole lines of one strong take and cut where the ear cannot follow the join.

Updated · 5 min read Lesson 8 of 12 in Vocal Production

In short

  1. A sung line is one physical gesture, so level, tone and pitch move together across it. A word-by-word comp breaks that shape at every splice.
  2. A crossfade removes the click at a join. It does not remove a jump in tone or intensity between two takes.
  3. Start from the best whole take, swap whole lines, and cut just before hard consonants or in breaths.
In this lesson (8)

The perfect comp that feels cold

in a DAW makes it easy to slice a vocal into tiny pieces. Record ten takes, stack them in comp lanes, and pick the best word or even the best syllable from each. The result has every note in tune and every word clean.

Then it plays in the mix and the performance feels cold. It sounds like a sampled instrument playing the melody, not a person telling you something.

Why it matters

A line is one gesture

Singing a line is one physical gesture. Breath pressure builds, the voice gets brighter as it gets louder, and the singer leans into the big word and pulls back on the soft one. All of that changes together across the phrase, and that shared movement is what gives a line its arc.

Takes recorded minutes apart differ in all of it. The singer is in a slightly different mood, a little closer to the mic or further away, fresher or more tired. Stitch one line from five takes and those differences meet at every join. A crossfade removes the click, but it does not remove a jump in level, tone or intent. Listeners rarely pick out an edit as an edit. They hear a singer who seems to change their mind on every word.

Figure 1. The intensity of one line, drawn as a shape. Sung in one take it rises to the big word and falls away. Built word by word from different takes, it jumps at every join, so the line no longer seems to be going anywhere.

The science

What travels with a take

Several things belong to a take and do not survive being cut into pieces:

  • Level and arc. The line rises and falls in one shape.
  • Tone. Louder singing is brighter, and moving closer to a directional mic adds bass through the , so the same word from another take can have a different colour.
  • Pitch path. The way a singer slides from one note into the next belongs to that take. A cut between notes can join an approach from one take to a landing from another.
  • Breath and timing. A phrase is timed around the breath before it.

The ear is quick to notice the tone changes. In , sounds that change smoothly tend to be heard as one continuing source, while an abrupt change in is a cue that a new sound has started (Bregman, 1990). A word whose colour jumps away from its neighbours can stand out even when its pitch and level match.

This also tells you where to cut. A plosive such as p, t or k starts with a brief closure, a moment of near silence, so a join placed just before it is hard to hear. An s is noise, so a short crossfade inside it hides well, and a breath is a natural break. A cut in the middle of a vowel exposes every difference between the two takes.

Try it

Comp against one take

0 of 6 steps done

The base-take comp should hold together as one performance, with lines that build and land. The word-by-word comp may be cleaner on paper and still sound as if it has no direction.

Common mistake

Comping for pitch first

When pitch accuracy picks the pieces, a great, emotional phrase gets cut up because one note is slightly flat, and the note is replaced with an in-tune one from a weaker take. Pitch on one note can be corrected afterwards. The delivery of a phrase cannot be added later.

The second mistake is comping with your eyes. Pitch graphs and waveforms show you which take is tidy, not which one is convincing. Choose by ear first, then look.

Takeaway

Start from the best whole take

Comp for delivery and meaning first, then fix pitch on the take you kept. Use whole lines from as few takes as you can, and keep at least two consecutive lines from one take where possible, so the breathing and tone carry through. Cut before hard consonants or in breaths, never in the middle of a vowel. Mike Senior's chapter on comping in Mixing Secrets for the Small Studio is a good companion to this workflow.

Figure 2. A comping order that keeps the performance. Most of the line comes from one take, and every swap is a whole line unless a smaller one is unavoidable.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. Where is the safest place to cut between two vocal takes?
  2. A crossfade at a splice hides the click. What does it not hide?
  3. A phrase has the best delivery of the session, but one held note is slightly flat. What is the better move?

Sources

Show all 2
  • Bregman, A. S. (1990). Auditory Scene Analysis: The Perceptual Organization of Sound. MIT Press.
  • Senior, M. (2011). Mixing Secrets for the Small Studio. Focal Press.

Next lesson · 9 of 12

Fast retune speed erases the movement between notesA fast pitch corrector fixes the notes and flattens the scoops, slides and vibrato that carry the delivery. Use the slowest retune speed that keeps long notes in tune.

Previous: The bite of a vocal lives in its consonants

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.