Skip to content

Why a great vocal starts before the microphone

A strained vocal is usually recorded that way. Too much backing in the headphones makes a singer push, and no EQ can undo how a pushed voice sounds.

Updated · 6 min read Lesson 1 of 12 in Vocal Production

In short

  1. When singers cannot hear themselves, they push without meaning to. A pushed voice is louder, brighter and harder to tune all at once.
  2. That change runs through the whole harmonic series, so a cut at one frequency in the mix makes the vocal duller without making it relaxed.
  3. Turn the backing down in the cue before you touch the vocal chain, and compare the takes at matched level.
In this lesson (8)

The harshness you cannot EQ out

You spend an hour on a lead vocal that sounds thin and hard. You dip 3 kHz, try a tube , add a saturator. Each move trades one problem for another, and the vocal still sounds like the singer was fighting the track.

That fight happened during the take. When singers cannot hear themselves over the backing in their headphones, they push. A pushed voice differs from a relaxed one in level, tone, pitch and phrasing, and plugins only ever work on the result.

Why it matters

Effort changes the whole sound

Effort is not a volume knob the singer turns. To sing louder, the vocal folds close faster and more firmly on every cycle. That strengthens the upper relative to the , so a louder voice is also a brighter one, and many singers tighten the throat to get there, which listeners hear as strain.

The brightness lands across the whole spectrum, including the region from about 2 to 4 kHz where the ear is most sensitive. So when you cut 3 kHz in the mix, you remove one slice of the change and the vocal turns dull without sounding relaxed. Compressing it forward has its own cost: a loud cue leaks out of the headphones into the microphone, and every decibel of compression on the vocal also brings up that bleed in the gaps.

Figure 1. The same note sung relaxed and pushed, drawn as a shape and lined up at the bottom of the range. Pushing keeps more energy in the upper harmonics, so the voice gets brighter as it gets louder, most audibly where the ear is most sensitive.

The science

The Lombard effect

In 1911 the French doctor Étienne Lombard described how people raise their voices when noise stops them hearing themselves. The Lombard effect has been found in many species since and is largely automatic (Brumm and Zollinger, 2011). Speech produced in noise is louder, longer and higher in pitch, and its vowel spectra shift as well (Summers and colleagues, 1988).

Singers do the same. In a study where singers performed along with a choir played over headphones, they got louder as the choir got louder, and they held back only partly when told to resist it (Tonkinson, 1994). For a singer in a booth, a loud backing track in the cue does the same job as the noise in those studies: it masks their own voice.

Hearing less of yourself costs accuracy too. When singers' hearing of their own voice was masked with noise, their intonation got worse, and they had to rely on the feel of the throat and breath, which is less precise (Mürbe and colleagues, 2002).

A rule of thumb follows, in words rather than a formula: the louder the backing is relative to the singer's own voice in the cue, the harder they push and the less accurately they tune. The fix sits in the cue mix, which you control.

Figure 2. The loop a loud cue starts. The backing masks the voice, the singer pushes and asks for more, and if the whole cue goes up the backing still masks the voice, only louder.

Try it

Two takes, one cue change

Try this at the start of your next vocal session. Keep the singer's headphone volume knob where it is for both takes.

0 of 6 steps done

The second take usually needs less : less edge in the upper mids, steadier held notes and less backing audible in the pauses. Level-matching matters because the pushed take is louder, and louder tends to sound better at first.

Common mistake

Solving comfort with plugins

When a singer says they cannot hear themselves, the quick answer is to put a heavy compressor on the cue vocal or to turn up the headphone amp. A heavy compressor flattens their dynamics in their own ears, so they lose the sense of how hard they are singing and either push or hold back. A few decibels of gentle compression is fine. Turning up the headphone amp makes everything louder, the backing included, which brings back the along with more bleed and faster .

Takeaway

Set the cue before the chain

Before you open the vocal chain, set the cue. Bring the backing down until the singer can hear their own voice clearly, keep the vocal dry or close to it, and keep the headphone level as low as feels good. Solo the mic in a pause to check for bleed. A relaxed singer gives you a take that needs less EQ, less compression and less tuning. How to build the cue itself, reverb and included, is covered in the lesson on headphone balance.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. Why does a cut around 3 kHz rarely fix a vocal that was sung pushed?
  2. A singer asks for "more me" in the headphones. What is the better first move?
  3. In the two-take experiment, why level-match before comparing?

Sources

Show all 4
  • Brumm, H., & Zollinger, S. A. (2011). The evolution of the Lombard effect: 100 years of psychoacoustic research. Behaviour, 148(11-13), 1173-1198.
  • Mürbe, D., Pabst, F., Hofmann, G., & Sundberg, J. (2002). Significance of auditory and kinesthetic feedback to singers' pitch control. Journal of Voice, 16(1), 44-51.
  • Summers, W. V., Pisoni, D. B., Bernacki, R. H., Pedlow, R. I., & Stokes, M. A. (1988). Effects of noise on speech production: Acoustic and perceptual analyses. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 84(3), 917-928.
  • Tonkinson, S. (1994). The Lombard effect in choral singing. Journal of Voice, 8(1), 24-29.

Next lesson · 2 of 12

Headphone balance changes the takeA singer tunes and times against what the headphones tell them. Set their own voice, the reverb and the latency in the cue before you blame the take.
Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.