Skip to content

How breath can make a vocal feel closer

Deleting or gating every breath makes a vocal sound pasted together. Keep the breaths, turn them down before compression, and the singer stays in the room.

Updated · 5 min read Lesson 6 of 12 in Vocal Production

In short

  1. A breath tells the listener a person is close and that a line is coming. Deleting it leaves gaps of dead silence between phrases.
  2. Compression shrinks the gap between words and breaths, so a natural breath can come out of the chain sounding like a gasp.
  3. Lower breaths with clip gain before the compressor instead of deleting or gating them.
In this lesson (8)

The vocal that sounds too clean

During editing, the temptation is to clean up everything. You run strip silence or put a gate on the lead vocal, and the spaces between phrases go quiet. On playback, the vocal sounds pasted into the song. Each line starts out of nothing and stops dead.

Breaths are part of how a person sings, and part of how a listener hears that a person is singing.

Why it matters

Breath tells the listener someone is there

Breath is quiet. In everyday life you only hear someone breathe when you are close to them. A close vocal mic hears it the same way, so a breath on a record reads as closeness. It also carries timing and intent: a quick sip of air sets up a fast line, a deep inhale warns that a big note is coming.

There is evidence that listeners use these sounds. When Whalen, Hoequist and Sheffert (1995) put a natural breath before synthetic sentences, listeners transcribed and recalled them better. Replacing the breath with rustling leaves, a sound with a similar spectrum, gave no benefit.

Deleting breaths costs more than the breath. Under every vocal there is room tone and a little headphone bleed. When you cut each gap to dead silence, that background stops and starts with every phrase, and on headphones the vocal seems to drop out between lines.

Figure 1. Three ways to handle the gap between two phrases, drawn as level shapes. Lowering the breath keeps the line continuous. Deleting it drops the vocal to dead silence, so the room under the voice stops and starts. A gate does the same and also clips the end of the first phrase and the start of the second.

The science

Why compression makes breaths loud

The reason producers want breaths gone is often the . A breath that sounds fine in the raw take can come out of the vocal chain sounding like a gasp, because compression shrinks the gap between the loud words and the quiet breath.

Take words peaking at -10 and a breath at -30 dBFS, 20 dB below. A compressor with its threshold at -20 dBFS and a 4:1 ratio brings the words down to -17.5 dBFS: they were 10 dB over the threshold and come out 2.5 dB over. The breath is under the threshold, so the compressor leaves it alone. Then makeup gain of 7.5 dB brings the words back to -10 dBFS and lifts the breath to -22.5 dBFS. While the breath stays under the threshold, the standard gain computer of a compressor (Giannoulis, Massberg and Reiss, 2012) gives the new gap as:

Δafter=Δbefore−(Lword−T)(1−1R)\Delta_{\text{after}} = \Delta_{\text{before}} - \left(L_{\text{word}} - T\right)\left(1 - \frac{1}{R}\right)

Here Δ\Delta is the gap between word and breath in decibels, LwordL_{\text{word}} the word peak, TT the threshold and RR the ratio. With these numbers, 20 dB becomes 12.5 dB. Every compressor or after it on the vocal or the mix bus shrinks the gap again.

Figure 2. Words peaking at -10 dBFS and a breath at -30 dBFS through a 4:1 compressor with its threshold at -20 dBFS, then 7.5 dB of makeup gain. The breath sits under the threshold, so it is only lifted: the gap shrinks from 20 dB to 12.5 dB. Cutting the breath by 8 dB first puts it 20.5 dB below the words again.

Try it

Three versions of the same gap

0 of 6 steps done

Copy A should sound edited, copy B should clip the soft ends of words, and copy C should sound continuous, with breaths that sit under the words instead of over them.

Common mistake

The gate, or no editing at all

A gate on a lead vocal saves editing time and costs detail. It only knows level, and the quiet starts and ends of words sit at the same level as the breaths, so it clips them too. Near the threshold it also chatters open and shut on bleed.

The opposite mistake is leaving every breath at its raw level in front of heavy compression, a and a limiter. Each stage lifts the breaths a little more, and by the master they compete with the words.

Takeaway

Turn breaths down, not off

Edit breaths before the vocal chain. Lower most of them by 6 to 10 dB with , delete only the ones that are clicks, pops or bleed, and use short fades so nothing starts or stops with a click. Leave a breath at full level when it sets up a big line or lands as part of the rhythm. The singer stays close to the listener, and the compressor stops working against you.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. Words peak at -10 dBFS and a breath sits at -30 dBFS. A 4:1 compressor at -20 dBFS, with makeup gain that brings the words back to -10, leaves the breath where?
  2. What does a gate on a lead vocal usually cut along with the breaths?
  3. Why does a vocal with every breath deleted often sound pasted together?

Sources

Show all 2
  • Giannoulis, D., Massberg, M., & Reiss, J. D. (2012). Digital dynamic range compressor design: A tutorial and analysis. Journal of the Audio Engineering Society, 60(6), 399-408.
  • Whalen, D. H., Hoequist, C. E., & Sheffert, S. M. (1995). The effects of breath sounds on the perception of synthetic speech. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 97(5), 3147-3153.

Next lesson · 7 of 12

The bite of a vocal lives in its consonantsConsonants are the quietest, shortest parts of a vocal and the parts that tell words apart. A slow release and an over-eager de-esser wear them down first.

Previous: How proximity effect turns warmth into mud

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.