Skip to content

Why delivery specs save the song

Before anyone hears your WAV, it is encoded, decoded and turned up or down, and a delivery spec is the list of what it has to survive.

Updated · 6 min read Lesson 44 of 44 in Mixing & Mastering

In short

  1. After upload, your master is measured, encoded to a lossy format, decoded on a device and turned up or down by normalization.
  2. Encoding and reconstruction can both push peaks above the WAV, so the true-peak ceiling has to leave room for them.
  3. Deliver what each destination asks for, meter an encoded copy before release, and keep an unlimited premaster for everything else.
In this lesson (8)

The upload that sounded different

You finish the master. It sounds clear and deep in the studio, and you send a 24-bit WAV to your distributor. Weeks later, on a streaming app, the top end is harsher and the loudest kicks crackle. You reload the WAV, check the meters and find no anywhere.

The listener never heard your WAV. On the way, it was measured, encoded to a lossy format, decoded on a phone and turned up or down by . A delivery spec is the list of things your master has to survive on the way.

Why it matters

Your file is processed after you let go

Services do their own processing. Spotify says it prepares the compressed and lossless streams itself from one high-quality stereo master per track, and its advice is written for lossy formats such as Ogg Vorbis and AAC. Apple publishes the commands it uses to encode masters to 256 kbps AAC at ingest, so you can audition that encode yourself (Apple, 2021).

Each of those steps can change your peaks. EBU Tech 3343 lists lossy coding among the processes that create above the original sample level, along with the converters and converters that follow.

Figure 1. Every step after your master can change its peaks. The encoder stores an approximation of the wave, the decoder and converter rebuild it, and any stage with a fixed maximum level clips what rises above full scale.

The science

What each step can do to the master

Measurement. The service reads integrated loudness with ITU-R BS.1770 and sets a playback gain. On Spotify's Normal setting, a master louder than -14 is turned down. A quieter one is raised only until its peaks reach -1 dB, so a dynamic master with high peaks may not be raised at all. The Loud setting is the exception: it raises soft tracks regardless of true peak and catches them with a .

Encoding. A lossy encoder stores an approximation of your waveform that should sound the same. The decoded wave is a different wave, and it can peak higher than the original, more so on loud, dense masters. That is why Apple tells you to check the encoded file for clipping, as well as the 24-bit master.

Decoding and conversion. The device rebuilds the continuous wave from samples. That wave can crest between samples, and any stage with a fixed maximum level clips what goes past full scale.

That is why the true-peak ceiling is lower than 0. The numbers come from the documents that set them:

ItemSpec
FileOne high-quality stereo master per track (Spotify)
ResolutionThe original 24-bit PCM file (Apple Digital Masters)
True peakBelow -1 dBTP, or -2 dBTP if louder than -14 LUFS (Spotify)
Ceiling-1 dBTP for PCM, -2 dBTP for some broadcast codecs (EBU)
ClippingNone, in the WAV or in an encoded test (Apple)

Different destinations have different limits. Vinyl struggles with loud high frequencies and with bass that is out of between the channels, so cutting engineers usually want a separate, less limited master. Ask before you send one file everywhere.

Try it

Audition the encode

0 of 6 steps done

On loud material the encoded copy often reads higher than the WAV. The difference signal shows you where the codec works hardest, usually in the top end and around .

Common mistake

One master for every destination

One loud master goes everywhere: to streaming, to the vinyl cutter and into your archive. Limiting cannot be undone, so keep an unlimited premaster for remasters, vinyl and formats you have not thought of yet.

The other mistake is trusting normalization to fix level problems. It changes gain and nothing else. It will not limit a loud master, it will not clean up overs that are already in the file, and on the Normal setting it will not raise a quiet master past the point where its peaks would clip.

Takeaway

Deliver to the destination

Set a true-peak ceiling of -1 , or -2 dBTP for masters louder than -14 LUFS going to Spotify. Before release, meter an encoded copy as well as the WAV. Deliver each destination the file it asks for, and keep a premaster the final limiter has not touched. How true peak works in detail is in the lesson on true peak after encoding.

3 questions

Check yourself

  1. You line up an AAC copy with your WAV to the sample, flip its polarity and play both. What do you hear?
  2. A dynamic master is quieter than -14 LUFS and peaks near 0 dBTP. What does Spotify's Normal setting do?
  3. Why keep an unlimited premaster when you deliver a loud streaming master?

Sources

Show all 6

Lesson 44 of 44

You reached the end of Mixing & Mastering

That was the last of 44 lessons in this path. The next path is Audio Science, 14 lessons.

Audio Science, lesson 1Sampling is taking photos of airDigital audio is not a staircase. The sample rate sets the highest frequency a file can hold, and the converter plays one smooth wave through the samples.

Back to the Mixing & Mastering pathAll pathsAll lessons

Previous: Sequencing changes perceived quality

Portrait of Virzy Guns

Written by Virzy Guns

Songwriter and producer, founder of Virzy Guns Production. Now building HealingWave.